ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s hard to win”

How many would go 7 and 1 with a QB you said probably wouldnt start on any p5 teams? And against 2 top 15 teams

Put it all in perspective

All I’m saying is he better be replacing an OC after this year or he’ll be gone himself soon enough. That has to be one of the Top10 worst offensive halves in ND history(not that the defense deserves any credit for that half either).
 
Oh you’re a much better fan than us. Grow up. We’ve all watched the same team yet some of us are more realistic than others. This team is the epitome of up and down. Next year with more experience, there will be more ups than downs. So suck it up.
There’s no reason for this or any team to be this extreme up and down
 
Agree but we’ve played 5 really really bad teams this year and lost to 2 of them and almost lost to 2 others … we clearly should have crushed them even with pyne … UNC and Clemson show even with pyne what this team is capable of, no one expects us to play that good weekly but the drop off shouldn’t be this extreme
Hard to get up every week. Esp against a schedule like ours.

Every team has those games. But they have a guy that can erase that. We dont

Book and Coan got us out of losses when we played down to our competition. We dont have a QB

That wears on a team
 
All I’m saying is he better be replacing an OC after this year or he’ll be gone himself soon enough. That has to be one of the Top10 worst offensive halves in ND history(not that the defense deserves any credit for that half either).
Top 10…. It might be all time, guaranteed top 3 worst halves all time
 
  • Like
Reactions: NotreDomer1
Hard to get up every week. Esp against a schedule like ours.

Every team has those games. But they have a guy that can erase that. We dont

Book and Coan got us out of losses when we played down to our competition. We dont have a QB

That wears on a team
When you have what should be dominant lines on both sides that should mask inconsistencies
 
All I’m saying is he better be replacing an OC after this year or he’ll be gone himself soon enough. That has to be one of the Top10 worst offensive halves in ND history(not that the defense deserves any credit for that half either).
He could be like Kelly if he gets a decent QB. So he'll be here for a while. We could win 9 to 11 games a year with Rees and a solid QB. We've seen it

If MF wants to take the program to the next level, he'll need to change the OC and get a QB
 
Top 10…. It might be all time, guaranteed top 3 worst halves all time

Im not looking it up so I gave myself some wiggle room, but it be tough to outdo the ineptitude of today’s 2nd half. Against a 3-7 team no less.
 
He could be like Kelly if he gets a decent QB. So he'll be here for a while. We could win 9 to 11 games a year with Rees and a solid QB. We've seen it

If MF wants to take the program to the next level, he'll need to change the OC and get a QB

agreed, but that’s assuming Rees can get and develop a top QB to begin with. So far, that hasn’t showed as a realistic reality.
 
Next week’s offensive game plan is TE(QB) sneaks. Its guaranteed to improve our offensive output. 😂
 
We won so no its not top anything.

We packed it in because we had a big lead

Worst halves were when we stunk it up and then lost
We did not pack it in…. Rees called PA shots all second half but pyne wouldn’t throw the ball to wide open wrs and instead took sacks vs cover

We lost the second half 19-0 and had 2 yards… this is about a half of football not the entire game
 
agreed, but that’s assuming Rees can get and develop a top QB to begin with. So far, that hasn’t showed as a realistic reality.
He coached Book and Coan so we can be a good team with Rees was my point

Taking the next step I think we need a new Oc
 
We did not pack it in…. Rees called PA shots all second half but pyne wouldn’t throw the ball to wide open wrs and instead took sacks vs cover 0
Pyne shut down. I think he needs to see a shrink. He was super emo girl acting in the pocket
 
Hard to get up every week. Esp against a schedule like ours.

Every team has those games. But they have a guy that can erase that. We dont

Book and Coan got us out of losses when we played down to our competition. We dont have a QB

That wears on a team
Tell us how running 33 times and getting 38 yards when your QB goes 17 of 21 for 269 yards and 4 TD’s is indicative of poor QB play
 
We did not pack it in…. Rees called PA shots all second half but pyne wouldn’t throw the ball to wide open wrs and instead took sacks vs cover

We lost the second half 19-0 and had 2 yards… this is about a half of football not the entire game
Yeah we packed it in. Effort was low. Playcalling and no Estime was a joke

He shouldnt have been calling PA. They were blitzing like crazy playing cover 0. We were calling PA and trying to throw deep. Stupidity.

We got blitzed like crazy in the 2nd half.
 
Yeah we packed it in. Effort was low. Playcalling and no Estime was a joke

He shouldnt have been calling PA. They were blitzing like crazy playing cover 0. We were calling PA and trying to throw deep. Stupidity.

We got blitzed like crazy in the 2nd half.
That’s not packing it in

but we agree in estime and I agree quick slants or screens would have worked easily
 
He coached Book and Coan so we can be a good team with Rees was my point

Taking the next step I think we need a new Oc

Coached. Didn’t recruit or develop them. They weren’t great QB’s either. Book couldn’t hit a downfield pass to save his life and Coan was an absolute statue.

But yes, we did win games with them so I get your point
 
Coached. Didn’t recruit or develop them. They weren’t great QB’s either. Book couldn’t hit a downfield pass to save his life and Coan was an absolute statue.

But yes, we did win games with them so I get your point
Why is Ian Book on the Philadelphis Eagle's roster if he is so pathetic?
 
I think u look at the film from Marshall, Stanford, Navy and you say to the players that are dogging it that if u don’t show major improvement and play 4/4 of football yer ass is done
 
Coached. Didn’t recruit or develop them. They weren’t great QB’s either. Book couldn’t hit a downfield pass to save his life and Coan was an absolute statue.

But yes, we did win games with them so I get your point
Oh he definitely developed Book. He coached him his whole career. Book was an average recruit with average tangibles and got him drafted.

Coan was a statue, thats not on Rees. Getting what he did out of a statue should be a compliment

Neither were great QBs obviously. And we still won a lot. Thats my point
 
Oh he definitely developed Book. He coached him his whole career. Book was an average recruit with average tangibles and got him drafted.

Book never got better YOY is what I’m saying regarding his development.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT