Anyone have any inside info?
https://irishsportsdaily.com/s/7752/breaking-ian-book-out-for-florida-state
https://irishsportsdaily.com/s/7752/breaking-ian-book-out-for-florida-state
Book out vs FSU?
- Thread starter Get Nasty
- Start date
Maybe. The way it sounds is he is banged up and sits it out this week. He probably can play if needed. I bet he dresses .
That's what I'm hopeful for and would make more sense. I think Kelly might have said something Tuesday if it was broken ribs and he was out for an extended period.
Kelly is also full of crap, and not to be taken seriously in PCs as we all know. He said there were no injuries that would keep anyone out for FSU.
BK owes it to no one to divulge any injury info or just about anything else. He's trying to get to the playoffs. Not worry about message board chatter.. There are also HIPAA laws in the state of Indiana that might be in play here, but, I don't know if sports related injuries are covered by this law. Lying is one thing. Not divulging info is in play as far as I'm concerned.
I'm 100% good with holding the info until now, don't get me wrong. BUT, if book has cracked ribs, Kelly lied, i'm not ok with him lying.
"BUT, if book has cracked ribs, Kelly lied, i'm not ok with him lying."
And why do you need to know? Why does Kelly need to reveal injuries to anyone?
Back to the guy was supposedly moving to RB? Well, 9-1 isn't awful I guess. At least we won't have to watch the playoff show next week.
Are you not followin? He doesn't need to divulge injuries, but he shouldn't come out and say "no injuries occurred in the NW game that would keep anyone out for FSU."
"Well, 9-1 isn't awful I guess. At least we won't have to watch the playoff show next week."
THERE's the positive spirit! So, why even play the game Saturday night then... guess we know you won't be wasting your time watching...I mean, you already know the outcome!
Dumb post of the week award here
Kelly will get away with it because no one will call him out on it, that's the rules with the media and the pathetic soft ND writers.
I didn’t see the headline but ESPN is saying cracked ribs definitely ? or that he’s out with possible cracked ribs? Anyone see ?
With BW at the helm this team loses to Stanford, VT, Pitt, and NW. The only saving grace is FSU absolutely sucks, but their game plan just got a whole lot easier. Load the box, shut down the run game, and let BW shit all over himself and his team.
I don't condone lying either. Under any circumstances. Was he asked specifically about Ian or did he make the comment about injuries in general?
Just got an update from Score that he has been ruled out for Saturday night. Not good.
With IB: ND - 42 fsu -17
With BW ND - 24 fsu -21
With IB: ND - 42 fsu -17
With BW ND - 24 fsu -21
oh no ! a coached lied ! off with his head !
Honestly, redshirting is pretty pointless in today's games. If he's good enough he'll be in the NFL before he uses all his eligibility. If he's not he'll get passed over.
One game. So he could play three more and still red-shirt. Hopefully he's been getting meaningful reps this fall.
Hairline fracture and low grade kidney contusion isn't something that is just about "feeling" they're monitoring the situation closely with scans
ND loses every game with wimbush as QB, except ND is 3-0 with wimbush as QB. Weird
True Fr play all the time now in CFB; Bowman and Lawrence this year. Tua at 'Bama won them the NC game last year. Fr play all the time now
It's the crappy ND Media/ ND Football relationship where there is no accountability, no real questions, no follow up. BK was being asked how numbers are handed out to frosh, are you F'n kidding me.
All of the above had meaninful reps vs much much lesser opponents (even though fsu is bad) before being thrust into the spot light in a big moment, Jurk hasn't had that yet.
Oh come on, that Michigan team, as of now, would have beat our ass with Wimbush at quarterback. Surely you aren't that dumb?
