What is your point?The majority of people think a lot of things should be a certain way and they aren t.
What is your point?The majority of people think a lot of things should be a certain way and they aren t.
I guess I can say the same to you. Just because the majority of people as you say think something is bad or wrong doesn't t mean it's against the law or a violation of some other kind. It's part of our freedoms. I don t care for the sitting one bit. Kneeling with a bowed head doesn't bother me in the least.What is your point?
My point is that the majority of fans think it is disrespectful. It is not a win for the NFL. Of course they have the right to do it and fans have the right to boo or stop watching etc.I guess I can say the same to you. Just because the majority of people as you say think something is bad or wrong doesn't t mean it's against the law or a violation of some other kind. It's part of our freedoms. I don t care for the sitting one bit. Kneeling with a bowed head doesn't bother me in the least.
Absolutely. Again I think sitting is very disrespectful. Kneeling with head bowed, not at all.My point is that the majority of fans think it is disrespectful. It is not a win for the NFL. Of course they have the right to do it and fans have the right to boo or stop watching etc.
I do ! Before every Irish game ! No song gets me more fired up than the battle hymn !
*** I get your genius IrishDJ ! Both the North and South soldiers sang it during the civil war ! Maybe Under the Domers could get together and sing a chorus together !
You can always count on the house moron to add something inane to the thread. He seldom disappoints.When less than half the voters "elect" a moronic lying traitor it is hard to have respect for a flag that has a fake president representing values that dont actually represent the views
of a majority of its people.
So it's my fault that your reasoning started out with it being a "silly ritual to a piece of cloth" into that tirade that you just posted? Maybe your side should be more understanding that my side views your protests as complete and utter disrespect to our country and those who've served. I don't have to piss in your dad's coffin to get you to start a conversation with me, do I? Pick a different venue for your protest.
Its too bad that you can't recognize the difference between a tirade and a statement. I have a very strong opinion as to the anthem and the pledge. You have a very strong opinion as to both also. Isn't that was our service members fought for - so we can have, and voice, differing opinions? How is exercising a right that is the linchpin of the Constitution considered to be disrespectful?
What with so much wrong in this country why don't you and all the bleeding heart liberals who fester in this cesspool of negativity take your idoligy and peddle it outside of this country. Let their citizens fight and die so you can vent your disrespect and doom and gloom? Oh yes, be sure to do it in a "safe" place.NotreDomer1, with all due respect, you need to get your head out of your ass. Its not a question of whether it is difficult to stand up for an anthem. It is whether or not I, as well as others, choose to stand up. Honoring a country and everything good it stands for is pointless unless, and until, you are able to recognize everything bad about this country. There is a lot that is good and a lot that is bad. The fact that we are still battling racism and that our Dear Leader takes days before he will recognize that neo-Nazis and white supremacists are bad people is both bad and an embarrassment. The fact that we still don't have affordable healthcare for all people is both bad and an embarrassment. The fact that our political system is so corrupt is bad. The fact that Congress fails or refuses to actually acknowledge fiscal responsibility is bad. The fact that we spend so much on the military while our bridges are crumbling and we have other serious infrastructure issues is bad. The fact that we are even talking about building a wall rather than spending money to actually help the poor and middle-class is bad. Why would I want to get my fat ass out of my seat to honor those issues?
There's a time and a place for your protests. .
very true. that's why protesters choose high visibility forums like the anthem. maximizes attention. It's why people collecting for charity go downtown
And for all the talk of "This isn't the right way" I haven't heard any suggestions of what would be acceptable
who determines the appropriate time and place ?Hello, USMC here....
It's too bad you can't figure out that I'm not against the 1st amendment. There's a time and a place for your protests. The singing of the National Anthem isn't that time or place. There wouldn't be a 1st amendment without the sacrifices of our veterans. You should not be disrespecting the very people who've allowed you to have the ability to voice your opinions. If anything, that should be the part of your protest that you celebrate most.
who determines the appropriate time and place ?
very true. that's why protesters choose high visibility forums like the anthem. maximizes attention. It's why people collecting for charity go downtown
And for all the talk of "This isn't the right way" I haven't heard any suggestions of what would be acceptable
The same piece of clothing that covers the casket of my fallen brothers I find that comment extremely offensive."Silly ritual to a piece of cloth"?
What a thing to say. Don't get me wrong, it's your right to say it, but it's my right to call you a jackass for doing so.
That's a question better posed to the people who actually did the fighting to maintain those treasured rights that Americans have.Its too bad that you can't recognize the difference between a tirade and a statement. I have a very strong opinion as to the anthem and the pledge. You have a very strong opinion as to both also. Isn't that was our service members fought for - so we can have, and voice, differing opinions? How is exercising a right that is the linchpin of the Constitution considered to be disrespectful?
Duck, totally agree with your statement about differing opinions and the right to express same, and the fact our military service has and continues to sacrifice for us to enjoy this right. I totally disagree with your conclusion delivered as a question that suggests exercising this right can therefore never be disrespectful. Of course a given act can be disrespectful and ugly and vulgar and any variety of adjective, and still be exercised as one of our most important rights as guaranteed under the constitution. Burning the American flag as a statement of protest comes to mind.Its too bad that you can't recognize the difference between a tirade and a statement. I have a very strong opinion as to the anthem and the pledge. You have a very strong opinion as to both also. Isn't that was our service members fought for - so we can have, and voice, differing opinions? How is exercising a right that is the linchpin of the Constitution considered to be disrespectful?
Maybe you should read my post titled "Cowboys- Nat'l Anthem."
So for all of you out there who don't stand at home when the anthem plays, WHY DO YOU HATE OUR TROOPS?!!
When you have nothing else what would you expectThis is a preposterous allegation
This is a preposterous allegation
WRONG!No. According to many in this thread, standing means you love and support the troops and not standing means you disrespect the troops and hate America.
Better get your butt out of that Lazy Boy during the SSB wicker or your neighbors are going to start to boycott your business.
Except its from the War of 1812.I can see why that third verse isn't used. It seems to be celebrating the death of slaves, probably those who fought for the British in exchange for their freedom.
Except its from the War of 1812.
Damn right ! Trump didn't get five deferments so those overpaid sob's could take a knee !What with so much wrong in this country why don't you and all the bleeding heart liberals who fester in this cesspool of negativity take your idoligy and peddle it outside of this country. Let their citizens fight and die so you can vent your disrespect and doom and gloom? Oh yes, be sure to do it in a "safe" place.
Semper Fi!
The entire poem is about the bombardment of Fort McHenry by the British. I was responding to the point made about stanza 3. It is not about celebrating the death of slaves who joined the British. The British actually paritipated in more of a relocation effort than a fight for your freedom program. Around 4000 total were evacuated during the war. Some were re-enslaved on ships or in the Caribbean. Most estimate say the vast majority were transported to Bermuda and Nova Scotia. Around 200 fought in the Colonial Marines and a few hundred more were on ships in the British Navy. That being said, that particular stanza, as most of the poem is talking about the Americans and their withstanding of the shelling. It was actually a British Victory of sorts since they ran out of ammo and could not continue. But in the greater scheme of things, like most of the War it was a push as the Fort withstanding the Bombardment kept Baltimore in tact.
The entire poem is about the bombardment of Fort McHenry by the British. I was responding to the point made about stanza 3. It is not about celebrating the death of slaves who joined the British. The British actually paritipated in more of a relocation effort than a fight for your freedom program. Around 4000 total were evacuated during the war. Some were re-enslaved on ships or in the Caribbean. Most estimate say the vast majority were transported to Bermuda and Nova Scotia. Around 200 fought in the Colonial Marines and a few hundred more were on ships in the British Navy. That being said, that particular stanza, as most of the poem is talking about the Americans and their withstanding of the shelling. It was actually a British Victory of sorts since they ran out of ammo and could not continue. But in the greater scheme of things, like most of the War it was a push as the Fort withstanding the Bombardment kept Baltimore in tact.
Ludicrous conjecture and more of the nonsensical attempt to rewrite history to suit the liberal "destroy America" agenda.So lemme get this right.
The Corps of Colonial Marines consisted of three units composed of runaway slaves.
At least one of those units was part of the Battle of Baltimore, which included the bombardment of Fort McHenry.
Key was a slave owner who utilized his position as District Attorney for the City of Washington to go after abolitionists. He even attempted to have an abolitionist hanged for handing out abolitionist pamphlets (US vs. Reuben Crandall).
Key made several statements on record about how he considered black people inferior.
Key was on the HMS Tonnant during the entire Battle of Baltimore. He was there negotiating a prisoner's release and wasn't allowed to leave because he knew the positions of the British army and navy. It has been noted that slaves fled to British ships during the battle to escape slavery.
He then throws in this line into his poem:
"No refuge could save the hireling and slave
From the terror of flight or the gloom of the grave..."
Based on all of that, and considering that preceding lines on that stanza of the poem were talking trash to the British soldiers around him who thought the American forces would be easily routed, you don't think he's specifically talking trash any runaway slave he saw boarding British ships during the battle and saying there was nowhere for them to hide from the American forces other than the grave?
Sounds like he's gleefully wishing them dead to me. It might be a bit convoluted, but it's definitely smack talk for that time.