Depends upon the circumstances !....Yeah but what does your NFL cheerleader girlfriend say?.....
Depends upon the circumstances !....Yeah but what does your NFL cheerleader girlfriend say?.....
Time will tellIt's impossible to compare and we'll never know
Me too and though I am now way a Steelers fan it impressed me what he did there.Huge Jerome Bettis fan as a CFB RB. Top 3 I have ever watched in a ND uniform.
I’d put him in the conversation.You’d argue Audric Estime is “as good...” as Jerome Bettis as a CFB RB?
I would not.
Agree with that.We measure speed as an average. Time/distance. IT seems to me the most useful stat would be the speed in a 5 yd dash. Maybe at an unknown direction until the race starts.
ND has a track record of being “slow”. However they also have a track record of producing “slow” all pros that are vastly underrated and become pivotal game changers on NFL rosters. So, I guess I’ll take our chances with “slow”.Bettis ran in the 4.7's. Tony Rice ran a 4.7 at the combine. Ricky Watters ran a 4.71.
Watters then gained over 10,000 yds. rushing (plus hefty receiving yards) and may be the only player who's gained 1,000 or more yards for three different teams: SF, Philly, Seattle.
Rice and Watters were "officially" 4.5 guys coming into ND. But then, every running back EVER RECRUITED is supposedly 4.5 or better.
But is anyone thinking about how immeasureable in "REAL TIME" two-tenths of a second is?
One guy who was DEFINITELY TOP DRAWER FAST as an RB was Julius Jones who ran a 4.39. But again, we're talking tenths if not hundredths of a second.
Just for the record, here are some others. Some of these numbers are as per single runs; others composites.
Mark Green -- 4.62
Rocket -- 4.28
Tim Brown -- 4.39
Greg Bell -- 4.63
Darius Walker -- 4.56/4.61
Cierre Wood -- 4.46
Joey Getherall -- 4.38
Josh Adams -- 4.51
Willie Clark -- 4.44
Jeff Burris -- 4.59
Tony Brooks -- 4.77
Tom Zbikowski -- 4.54
Golden Tate -- 4.42
Allen Rossum -- 4.57
Jonas Gray -- 4.58
Michael Floyd -- 4.47
Dexter Williams -- 4.57
Harrison Smith -- 4.57
Juian Love -- 4.54/4.45
Kyle Hamilton -- 4.59
So what 40 time would eliminate a RB from consideration by an NFL teamND has a track record of being “slow”. However they also have a track record of producing “slow” all pros that are vastly underrated and become pivotal game changers on NFL rosters. So, I guess I’ll take our chances with “slow”.
Kyren and Kyle are only the most recent “slow” best rookies in the league. It’s a ND trend that I’m fine with. “Speed” is a stupid measurement with the broadest differential and room for day to day error.
For instance, a DL that didn’t take creatine or get enough sleep might put up 225 26 times instead of 28 times and nobody cares. That same guy can’t sleep because of nerves and runs a 4.76 instead of a 4.58 and everyone shits on them.
My take, watch the ****ing tape.
No chance he goes undrafted.He’s looking at UDFA! No college RB has ran a 40-time slower than 4.65 and been drafted since 2015. he can still make an NFL roster but he’s got a lot of work to do.
He doesn't play faster than that 4.71. He can still have a productive NFL career but he has never been a player that has a crazy burst. He is a build up speed guy.4.71, last of the RBs. Plays much faster on the field but this likely knocks him down to 5th round area.
He will have a chance, but if that's where he was testing he shouldn't have ran at the combine. Should have "pulled a hammy" or something and saved it for pro day.He'll have a chance to improve that number at his pro day. His vertical and broad jump were both good numbers
Yes he doesHe doesn't play faster than that 4.71. He can still have a productive NFL career but he has never been a player that has a crazy burst. He is a build up speed guy.
Kyren ran a 4.65 at combine then a 4.54 at pro dayHe will have a chance, but if that's where he was testing he shouldn't have ran at the combine. Should have "pulled a hammy" or something and saved it for pro day.
It was a mistake to run if he was testing pre combine slower than 4.65, which I think I saw in the last few years no rb over that level has been drafted.
He may have relegated himself to a big back role. I hope he's working with a trainer and shows out at pro day.
Not necessarily.Kyren ran a 4.65 at combine then a 4.54 at pro day
What he runs will only affect his draft stock. What role he has will be settled at camp
Maybe the sun dial was off.He’s looking at UDFA! No college RB has ran a 40-time slower than 4.65 and been drafted since 2015. he can still make an NFL roster but he’s got a lot of work to do.
Yes it will impact his draft positionNot necessarily.
Pro day isn't the same as the combine. At the combine most teams will make their minds up about those players.
If estime improves to 4.61... he's still likely to be regulated to a perceived big back role. Of course when he gets on a team that could change, but that perception will seriously impact his draft value.
I guess that's fair enough, but can he still be an effective RB? He's obviously a big back where they're not expecting breakaway speed. They're a cutoff point, I suppose, where you're simply too slow, regardless of the particular skill set. But I think 4.7 is well below that.He doesn't play faster than that 4.71. He can still have a productive NFL career but he has never been a player that has a crazy burst. He is a build up speed guy.
Not sure there is one if you are that good in college. Watch the tapeSo what 40 time would eliminate a RB from consideration by an NFL team
Would a 5.1 eliminate a RB ?Not sure there is one if you are that good in college. Watch the tape
You have to judge it positionally. It's a good tool to use but it's not the end all be allWhy do we even care what people run the 40 in? All the 40 is is straight line speed. Who in the NFL runs in a straight line? I looked up the average NFL players average 40 times and according to a 5 year combine report it is between 4.48 and 4.98 seconds. So he has average NFL speed. It’s what he does with that speed that matters.
Much faster when 240-275 lb. Opponents are chasing him!4.71, last of the RBs. Plays much faster on the field but this likely knocks him down to 5th round area.
It’s also referred to as “breakaway speed”Why do we even care what people run the 40 in? All the 40 is is straight line speed. Who in the NFL runs in a straight line? I looked up the average NFL players average 40 times and according to a 5 year combine report it is between 4.48 and 4.98 seconds. So he has average NFL speed. It’s what he does with that speed that matters.
Years ago I believe Jerry Allen who played for the Redskins had or tied the record for the longest run or reception at 99 yardsMuch faster when 240-275 lb. Opponents are chasing him!
So you think that the individual is more important than the team ?I’m just glad AE sat out the bowl game to train for the NFL combine.
Poor Pat, that humor went right over his dome
When did I say that?So you think that the individual is more important than the team ?
I agree, IrishJohn. I still have the memory of Jaylon Smith's horific injury in the bowl game.I’m just glad AE sat out the bowl game to train for the NFL combine.
Give it a rest NancyStill have the memory of Jaylon Smith. So am I.
And I wish Jaylon Smith would have done the same.Give it a rest Nancy
WE KNOW. WE GOT ITAnd I wish Jaylon Smith would have done the same.
Straw man argument. Nobody is running that in college football.Would a 5.1 eliminate a RB ?
Even if he can't run away from DBs, they're not looking for home runs typically, from someone like Estime. I sure thought he looked impressive as hell last season, and even though that definitely doesn't always predict NFL success, I think he's got a great shot. I'd like to think so at least. I suppose we had a pretty good line.As another poster said, watch the tape. These sacred measurables that some obsess over don’t always tell the whole story. Estime ran away from many DBs last season. He has a chance to be good whether he runs a 4.7 or a 4.5. It’s always nice to have more speed, but on the field speed doesn’t always translate into 40 times. I think he’s plenty fast enough to succeed if he’s off the charts in other areas, vision, toughness, pass pro, etc… We’ll see.
AssholeI agree, IrishJohn. I still have the memory of Jaylon Smith's horific injury in the bowl game.
RB's take a beating.
Like you've posted earlier, everyone is fast in the NFLIt’s also referred to as “breakaway speed”
A back that can’t be caught from behind is preferred to one who can be caught from behind
Linebackers and defensive lineman are incredibly fast in the modern NFL
Hence a running back’s speed is very important
Ergo, the 40