ADVERTISEMENT

Angelli Should be the starter.

I don’t think this debate about Leonard vs Angeli is all that clear cut. Angeli is the better passer, and he can run decently, but he is absolutely sack prone. Leonard is the better runner, in fact elite for a QB, but his passing is average at best, and he vacates the pocket way too early. Frankly, I don’t think either has the combination of skills needed to win a NC. Carr might, except for lack of experience. Hell, Minchey might, but we have damn near zero chance to see him play. We have the best QB room than we’ve had in years, just not sold that we have a current season NC caliber starter among them.

Football Notre Dame moves up a spot to 18th in coaches poll; AP poll drops at 2 ET

There wasn't a lot of room for movement up and down in the polls, as so many of the ranked teams won. USC remains ND's top-rated opponent, though the Trojans slipped a spot to No. 12, flip-flopping with Miami (Fla.). Louisville, ND's Sept. 28 home opponent is No. 20, while Texas A&M re-entered the coaches poll at No. 24 following its road-win at Florida on Saturday. ... I'll share my AP ballot when that poll comes out around 2 ET.

coaches.png
  • Like
Reactions: mcdermottrules

Today’s performance just proves my point about Freeman

Worse, a lefty


It's funny how partisan and identity politics find their way even in sports. But I think ND has largely remained outside this. Maybe even college football as a whole...compared to pro-sports.

ND is what it is because of general policies around admissions, majors, and matriculation. I follow pretty closely program management stuff and haven't seen egregious cultural war stuff...no, I don't believe Freeman was some so called diversity hire.

Occam's Razor: Freeman was a Faust, Davie, Willingham, and Weis hire. BK wasn't. Kind of clear pattern to me. Within the aforementioned context of policies preventing stacking top talent in depth.
  • Like
Reactions: christophero

The difference between week 1 - 3 is ND getting teams in 3rd and long...well and offense production

I'm really way beyond disappointed at how little poise Leonard shows in the pocket. And with 60 percent of our starting offensive line out -- and probably out for the entire season -- I think we are going to have some real problems down the road.
Though the competition on the OL was damn good in pre-season. Having Coogan and Rocco as backups is huge.
  • Like
Reactions: Telx1

Ga barely escapes

Good comments putting the GA game in proper context: elite teams find a way to win in all situations...especially the easier games.

Freeman let us down in this. Currently doesn't have what it takes to make us that. Learning on the job, to say the least.

I still love, root for, and will follow ND. But games like GA remind me of what the Irish once were. To my memories of my youth and Lou Holtz...when ND football used to mean something, with an appropriate culture in ND leadership driving it.

As I keep being told by some alumni here, I need to make do with the new normal about academic elitism. ND cannot possibly compromise, like the likes of GA do. I get it.

Take Purdue off the schedule

Time for new competition and add some value to schedule. Purdue is an awful football program right now. ND won 66-7 and had bad injuries
dumb
typical of todays I WANT IT NOW OR I AM GOING TO THROW A TANTRUM mentality

Purdue is up and down and right now its down but no reason to think it will NOT rise again
But YOU want to dump nearly a century of tradition because you WANT IT NOW

Ga barely escapes

Yes and there is no excuse for a team as talented as ND to lose to a MAC team at HOME. We've been told this team is a championship caliber team, Riley Leonard is a dynamic QB with a strong, accurate arm, who is mobile.

Also Kentucky is an SEC team, you are comparing apples to oranges.
and purdue is in the big ten.
there are lousy teams in all conferences but you seem unable to grasp that fact

Today’s performance just proves my point about Freeman

Ahhh, a good old pissing contest about how great a Notre Dame fan you are and what a vast storehouse of Irish informtation you posses...allow me to toss my credibility cap into the ring...

(It's times like these that I miss Oldbender's input...for those of you around awhile, you remember him...perhaps the most knowledgably and informative poster on here...right up there with the dear, departed Mr. Somogyi)

Anyway...are you a credible Notre Dame source on which to judge how big a spanking yesterday was? Future has seen 150 games all over the damn country (I assume none in Ireland?), whereas:

1) I obtained my graduate education at Notre Dame;
2) I have seen over 175 games around the country (with the tick stubs to prove it - see #8 below);
3) I obtained tickets for my parents to see the 1996 game in Dublin (had to work couldn't make it);
4) A distant (3rd or 4th cousin) from the Pennsylvania side of the family emigration from Ireland taught at Notre Dame for two years during WWII;
5) During my time at ND, I played catch for 30 minutes with Tom Clements on his way out of the Law School, during which time we discussed his career with the Hamilton Tiger-Cats, and his destruction thereof in the 1984 Grey Cup;
6) Bought Terry Andrysiak beers at a bar in Hamilton, Ontario while he was QB for the Tiger-Cats;
7) Had Lou Holts inquire as to my availability to walk-on while I was kicking and punting a few balls around the intramural fields one Sunday morning...he was crushed when I informed him I could not because I was a grad student and had no more eligibility;
8) I have 1135 catalogued pieces of Notre Dame memorabilia including programs, ticket stubs (see #2 above), jerseys, pennants, mini-footballs, min-helmets...

So, I think I am qualified to say this was one mo-fo ass-kicking, comparable to the 1996 Rutgers massacre at Notre Dame stadium (62-0), during which, by-the-way, I was installing a Notre Dame-themed ceiling fan in my parents' basement...

One must think like a child to address a child...
Ok
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT