ADVERTISEMENT

Underwood to Michigan

He had 221 yards of offense in his first game with on the road with a young OL and the game winning drive.

He and the offense has gotten much better since then. I think he'll be fine
221 yards of total offense? Really?? No shit??? By what ****ing metric in the history of the sport regardless of the circumstances is that even an average game for a QB???????????? Pay attention to the thread or STFU!
 
We haven't played 1 team that's close to what we will face to win a NC!!!!! IF & when that happens you, being part of the 1% that thinks we have a shot w/ him will have a very sad day! Again, if he makes that game winning play, I'm gladly gone!
Who said I don't enjoy it and don't tell me how to experience something I've been in love w/ for 54 years since I was 5!!!! Lastly you 1% homers it's ok to watch the game and want ND to win a 🏆 but, it's also possible to not be homer and admit what the rest of the fan base & country sees, fans like you are why people hate ND & their fans!
Yawn
 
RL can't throw a 🏈 into the ocean and there isn't a logical football fan across this country that doesn't know it...all except a very tiny portion of ND homers but, even across ND boards 99% of fans can see the ****ing obvious! 3rd & 10 game on the line against any of the top 5 and the games over!! His feet won't help him either against better athletes in that kind of a game! He's good on his feet but, he ain't Vick, Jackson or Daniels on his feet!!! He's dead in the water when this scenario arises if even does and if he makes a game winning play & not against the likes of BYU, Boise etc... I will gladly leave this board!🍀
You are removing 2 playoff teams from the equation? How about Miami? Are they out too? And Indiana? Remove them?

Then we're down to 7 teams, right?

If the OL plays well against any of those teams, RL will play well. If the OL struggles against any of those teams, RL will struggle too
 
Their a top 5 team????...pay attention to the thread...Their QB is worse than Leonard...no they are not an elite team! Stfu!!!
You said we haven't played 1 team that's close to what we will face to win a NC

Thats inaccurate. Their defense is of the level of many NC contenders

So try to comprehend or just STFU

That was a very stupid response from you. Try to keep up or again, STFU !!
 
You said we haven't played 1 team that's close to what we will face to win a NC

Thats inaccurate. Their defense is of the level of many NC contenders

So try to comprehend or just STFU

That was a very stupid response from you. Try to keep up or again, STFU !!
Their not making the playoffs idiot so no wrong again. And I clearly stated in my first post the teams were talking about is the top 5 and what will happen with the game on the line! Again try to follow along little man with the little 🧠!
 
Their not making the playoffs idiot so no wrong again. And I clearly stated in my first post the teams were talking about is the top 5 and what will happen with the game on the line! Again try to follow along little man with the little 🧠!
Doesn't matter if they make the playoffs, they have defensive talent like we will be facing in the playoff. I dont care if they make it or don't.

I'm sorry I'm not terrified of penn state like you seem to be lol

Pansy ass
 
  • Haha
Reactions: IrishMike409
We haven't played 1 team that's close to what we will face to win a NC!!!!! IF & when that happens you, being part of the 1% that thinks we have a shot w/ him will have a very sad day! Again, if he makes that game winning play, I'm gladly gone!
Who said I don't enjoy it and don't tell me how to experience something I've been in love w/ for 54 years since I was 5!!!! Lastly you 1% homers it's ok to watch the game and want ND to win a 🏆 but, it's also possible to not be homer and admit what the rest of the fan base & country sees, fans like you are why people hate ND & their fans!
Well then, I guess we're going to lose then. There's nothing to be done about it now. We're not switching QBs. And I don't think outsiders hate ND fans because they refuse to bitch and moan about their QB's passing deficiencies. That's just not one of the reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IrishMike409
Doesn't matter if they make the playoffs, they have defensive talent like we will be facing in the playoff. I dont care if they make it or don't.

I'm sorry I'm not terrified of penn state like you seem to be lol

Pansy ass
Who's afraid of PSU maybe in a locker room but, c'mon man here's the teams...Oregon, OSU, Texas, Alabama, Georgia & maybe Ole Miss & Miami...the way he throws the ball we have no chance on a neutral site especially with all the injuries! It's not happening but, if it does and he's the difference I will be the happiest ND fan in the world and gladly leave!!🍀
 
Well then, I guess we're going to lose then. There's nothing to be done about it now. We're not switching QBs. And I don't think outsiders hate ND fans because they refuse to bitch and moan about their QB's passing deficiencies. That's just not one of the reasons.
It's the delusion they can't stand and it doesn't just pertain to whether or not RL can throw a football better than me...JFC is it really that hard to understand what's being said and why?
 
It's not just Michigan it's pretty much every modern power and historic power in the sport serious about competing for national titles

they are spending upwards of 25 to 30 plus million a year in NIL on their roster but Notre Dame fans think they are going to win a national title by spending a few million on ACC 4th year seniors, bringing back their own fourth and fifth years, and signing three and four star prospects 😂
And Bryce flipped to LSU even though you said he wouldn’t….time for you to complain more about ND.

Quick question..how many NCs has Oregon won?
 
Colleges aren't refusing to pony up because they can't afford to -- or because it's not worth it -- they are refusing to pony up for political & economical power reasons
Yet here you are clamoring for exactly that…lol, you contradict yourself daily
 
Who's afraid of PSU maybe in a locker room but, c'mon man here's the teams...Oregon, OSU, Texas, Alabama, Georgia & maybe Ole Miss & Miami...the way he throws the ball we have no chance on a neutral site especially with all the injuries! It's not happening but, if it does and he's the difference I will be the happiest ND fan in the world and gladly leave!!🍀
Miami 🤣🤣🤣 Here's the teams....then includes Miami. Thanks for the laugh boss.

Texas....oh no, not mighty Texas with their big win being Vanderbilt. How can we compete with a team that struggles with Vandy. Oh noooo

Rel question, no BS. What has Texas done to be put in that category when you say we can't compete with them. Seriously.

There's no team on there that you put that we can't beat. There is no elite team this year
 
  • Like
Reactions: BGI User 756
As for whether or not Bryce Underwood is worth it I think any business investment comes with a certain degree of risk. So Even though Underwood may not specifically return 10 million it might still be a really good business practice to risk 10 million at the chance that a prospect of his caliber fully reaches his potential and the organization strikes gold
Haha. Sounds like you are the accountant for Cackle’s campaign
 
I applaud your confidence in your posts, truly. There’s no need to go into what economists and data analysts do on the board, no patronizing necessary.

This idea that “more schools would bid beyond 10M if it weren’t for the economic power struggle” is just a statement that you claim, with no actual data or source. It reminds me of the person who starts a claim off with “statistics say….” and never actually claim their source. I’m well aware of revenue sharing ideas and university’s reluctancy to share with the players.

That really doesn’t have much to do with paying a high school kid $10M. You see, recruiting in college is far more unpredictable than the NFL draft. So many more players, all different levels of competition, and the most difficult aspect of recruiting as a whole: will this player continue to improve and progress? Or, are they at their peak athletically. Thats a very difficult prediction for a 17/18 year old.

For instance the class of 2020 pro style QB’s on Rivals. #1 QB was DJ Uiagalelei, only other 5 star was QB #2 Harrison Bailey, no idea who he is today. 4 star CJ Stroud after them. So only 1 of these 3 is probably worth big money right? What are the odds someone realizes it’s neither 5 star at the time? After going over the top 20 QBs from that class, maybe 2 were even decent?

This idea teams pay all this money up front before athletes prove they can even play at this competition seems misguided, and somewhat foolish.

And maybe you’ll prove me wrong and there will be a line of teams waiting to spend $10M on a recruit. I would imagine if they do it’s from the pocket of the wealthiest of donors who aren’t looking for a good business decision.
Boom
 
  • Like
Reactions: Holycrossover3
Miami 🤣🤣🤣 Here's the teams....then includes Miami. Thanks for the laugh boss.

Texas....oh no, not mighty Texas with their big win being Vanderbilt. How can we compete with a team that struggles with Vandy. Oh noooo

Rel question, no BS. What has Texas done to be put in that category when you say we can't compete with them. Seriously.

There's no team on there that you put that we can't beat. There is no elite team this year
Delusional 1%! I'm out your a ****ing clueless child! Tell us all again about Riley's first round talent👨‍🦯
 
Delusional 1%! I'm out your a ****ing clueless child! Tell us all again about Riley's first round talent👨‍🦯
Tell us how we can't compete with mighty Miami Hurricanes 🤣🤣

Didn't they get beat by GT who we beat? They beat VT and Cal by 5 points combined

I mean how can we possibly compete with that

Aww you got in your feelings. Go run away you tool
 
It's hard to tell with Texas because they haven't played anyone good besides Georgia
We got tools to answer this question. That's why F+ and other advanced ranking systems exist.

Despite the head to head loss Texas has done more vs their schedule than Georgia has vs theirs which is why F+ has them rated higher.
Miami 🤣🤣🤣 Here's the teams....then includes Miami. Thanks for the laugh boss.

Texas....oh no, not mighty Texas with their big win being Vanderbilt. How can we compete with a team that struggles with Vandy. Oh noooo

Rel question, no BS. What has Texas done to be put in that category when you say we can't compete with them. Seriously.

There's no team on there that you put that we can't beat. There is no elite team this year
Texas has 11 five star players on their 85 man roster to NDs 1 five star player.

Texas is the #2 team in F+ through week 12 to NDs #8 F+ rank. Texas has the #1 defense to NDs #3 defense (but they also have a top 10 offense as well)

Am I the only person on this forum who gets really fed up with people doubling down/ arguing in the face of ever mounting evidence against their point of view? Only to return weeks later (after the evidence/data is proven correct) to continue to argue in the face of the evidence again and again and again (even with the benefit of hindsight)?

At what point does your desire for reality kick in and become more important than your ego?
 
We got tools to answer this question. That's why F+ and other advanced ranking systems exist.

Despite the head to head loss Texas has done more vs their schedule than Georgia has vs theirs which is why F+ has them rated higher.

Texas has 11 five star players on their 85 man roster to NDs 1 five star player.

Texas is the #2 team in F+ through week 12 to NDs #8 F+ rank. Texas has the #1 defense to NDs #3 defense (but they also have a top 10 offense as well)

Am I the only person on this forum who gets really fed up with people doubling down/ arguing in the face of ever mounting evidence against their point of view? Only to return weeks later (after the evidence/data is proven correct) to continue to argue in the face of the evidence again and again and again (even with the benefit of hindsight)?

At what point does your desire for reality kick in and become more important than your ego?
Thx Forrest
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pennick4
We got tools to answer this question. That's why F+ and other advanced ranking systems exist.

Despite the head to head loss Texas has done more vs their schedule than Georgia has vs theirs which is why F+ has them rated higher.

Texas has 11 five star players on their 85 man roster to NDs 1 five star player.

Texas is the #2 team in F+ through week 12 to NDs #8 F+ rank. Texas has the #1 defense to NDs #3 defense (but they also have a top 10 offense as well)

Am I the only person on this forum who gets really fed up with people doubling down/ arguing in the face of ever mounting evidence against their point of view? Only to return weeks later (after the evidence/data is proven correct) to continue to argue in the face of the evidence again and again and again (even with the benefit of hindsight)?

At what point does your desire for reality kick in and become more important than your ego?
You forgot one thing, I don't give a shit about F+. I think it's an embarrassment to ranking systems

I stopped reading when you used that as an example
 
The MAYBE made me

🤣🤣🤣🤣

What a stupid comment
1%...and someone who has never seen elite NC' ND football! I get it now!! Sad you have no idea, you never saw these guys in ND stadium or 27 other CFB stadiums around the country...you know guy's like Ross Browner or Luther Bradley or Joe Montana or Tim Brown or Rocket Ismail or Jerome Bettis or Bryant Young and I could go on and on and on! Hold onto your RL.
 
Last edited:
Do you think that ND would be 10-0 right now if Freeman had just started Angeli like you wanted, and that anyone who knows anything would agree with you?
I never said I wanted Angeli to start, I'm just pointing out a QB that can't pass when needed in 2025 is not winning ND a NC! The NC QB CJ Carr hopefully will be starting next year. The bottom line is RL is not first round talent and will not be able to make that 3rd & 10 against OSU, Oregon, Texas, Alabama or Georgia w/ the game on the line in a semifinal game hypothetically that he can even get us there. That's it, that's all, he's just not a good enough QB, period! The idiots that keep denying this again make up about 1% and make all other ND fans look like idiots.
 
Like Texas Am ?
I don't consider the A&M defense elite yet. Very good yes but not elite. Maybe in a year or 2 they will be. What I was really trying to say is that I believe we have better QBs sitting on the bench so more NIL money won't solve coaching choices of who to play and who not to play. RL got NIL money and we lost to NIU with less talent so giving more NIL money isn't always the solution. Maybe with a few key players it is but not across the board. In other words the team that pays out the most NIL isn't guaranteed a championship. Too many other factors.
 
I don't consider the A&M defense elite yet. Very good yes but not elite. Maybe in a year or 2 they will be. What I was really trying to say is that I believe we have better QBs sitting on the bench so more NIL money won't solve coaching choices of who to play and who not to play. RL got NIL money and we lost to NIU with less talent so giving more NIL money isn't always the solution. Maybe with a few key players it is but not across the board. In other words the team that pays out the most NIL isn't guaranteed a championship. Too many other factors.
We don't have better QBs sitting on the bench. Definitely not this year. Our top QBs on the bench are freshman and a sophomore and this isn't an easy offense to just pick up. And we need RLs legs with our OL situation.

That's the part you are missing
 
Do you think that ND would be 10-0 right now if Freeman had just started Angeli like you wanted, and that anyone who knows anything would agree with you?
They probably could be, and maybe would be. Assuming we beat A&M with Angeli, we probably would have beaten NIU, just because we would have, because almost any improvement in that game offensively would have resulted in a win. That's how close the game was, and how shitty NIU is. Maybe Louisville would have beaten us, that's possible too.

So RL is definitely the starting QB and no complaints or regrets. Personally, I'm fired up about him after a sluggish start. But yeah, we could be 10-0 with Angeli, very easily, very likely. What we could have done, should have done, is bench RL in the NIU game, and let Angeli pull out the win. With a presumed better passing game. The exact same way A&M beat LSU. And then just put RL back into the starting lineup. As a coach you're allowed to do that. So that would've been cool.
 
I never said I wanted Angeli to start, I'm just pointing out a QB that can't pass when needed in 2025 is not winning ND a NC! The NC QB CJ Carr hopefully will be starting next year. The bottom line is RL is not first round talent and will not be able to make that 3rd & 10 against OSU, Oregon, Texas, Alabama or Georgia w/ the game on the line in a semifinal game hypothetically that he can even get us there. That's it, that's all, he's just not a good enough QB, period! The idiots that keep denying this again make up about 1% and make all other ND fans look like idiots.
My apologies. You didn’t want Angeli starting at any point this year?
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT