ADVERTISEMENT

Can someone explain something ?

No no no. Balance is play calling mix. Rees has none so far
Variety is the type of plays in the play call mix ie pass plays can be screens, slants, pro, deep mid or short. Etc. Rees has minimal variety.
Consistency is opposite of not going flat in second half vs Navy. Having an offense vs Marshall n Stanford.

Rees is very inconsistent. So based on above Rees has a way to go. And I think a good qb can free him to be better
Rees went 21-4 in 2021 and 2020 for an 84 % winning percentage, that’s about as consistent as you can get.

You’re confusing failure to execute with play calling
 
Rees went 21-4 in 2021 and 2020 for an 84 % winning percentage, that’s about as consistent as you can get.

You’re confusing failure to execute with play calling
You are one dense and dull tool from a shed of rusty implements. Winning has very little to do with whether Rees is a good O coordinator.

Nobody on this board buys what you are selling. Nobody anywhere would accept your premise that winning is the prime criteria for an o coordinator being considered good.

Explain the inept o performance in Marshall, Ohio State, Stanford and second half Navy. Explain the lack of a passing game in any game this year that does not involve Mayer. Explain the inexcusable lack of second half offense vs Okla State.

I’m listening. Answer point by point By your measure, Rees has 3 losses squarely on his shoulders this year. Explain how those losses are not also on the defense or head coach. Because no one should get a pass and no one should be claimed to be a good o coordinator with 7 wins at ND. Maybe at Rutgers
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chitown11
You are one dense and dull tool from a shed of rusty implements. Winning has very little to do with whether Rees is a good O coordinator.

Nobody on this board buys what you are selling. Nobody anywhere would accept your premise that winning is the prime criteria for an o coordinator being considered good.

Explain the inept o performance in Marshall, Ohio State, Stanford and second half Navy. Explain the lack of a passing game in any game this year that does not involve Mayer. Explain the inexcusable lack of second half offense vs Okla State.

I’m listening. Answer point by point By your measure, Rees has 3 losses squarely on his shoulders this year. Explain how those losses are not also on the defense or head coach. Because no one should get a pass and no one should be claimed to be a good o coordinator with 7 wins at ND. Maybe at Rutgers
Yes!! Does Pattycakes ever wonder why he argues with so many people on this board? Maybe because he's not as smart as he thinks he is.
 
Proof? Because BK is my best friend and he told me. Its called "common sense", something you obviously don't have.
I knew that you didn’t have any concrete proof to back up your claim !
 
Yes!! Does Pattycakes ever wonder why he argues with so many people on this board? Maybe because he's not as smart as he thinks he is.
No, actually I think that it’s because ”pattycakes” doesn’t accept the bullshit that so many posters like you present as facts.

i‘d consider myself more of a “Devil’s Advocate” and rather objective as well.
 
You are one dense and dull tool from a shed of rusty implements. Winning has very little to do with whether Rees is a good O coordinator.
That has to be one of the all time dumbest statements ever made on this site. By your standards Rees at 12-0 isn‘t as good as the OC who goes 0-12
Nobody on this board buys what you are selling. Nobody anywhere would accept your premise that winning is the prime criteria for an o coordinator being considered good. Again, That has to be one of the all time dumbest statements made on this site. By your standards Rees at 12-0 isn‘t as good as the OC who goes 0-12.
Explain the inept o performance in Marshall, Ohio State, Stanford and second half Navy. Explain the lack of a passing game in any game this year that does not involve Mayer. Explain the inexcusable lack of second half offense vs Okla State. Failure to execute !

I’m listening. Answer point by point By your measure, Rees has 3 losses squarely on his shoulders this year. Explain how those losses are not also on the defense or head coach. Because no one should get a pass and no one should be claimed to be a good o coordinator with 7 wins at ND. Maybe at Rutgers. So according to you, when Ara went 7-2-1 he and his OC were terrible coaches.
You know nothing about football

On one hand you tell us that Reese’s 21-4 record isn’t indicative of him being a good OC, and then on the other hand yo say that a 7-3 record is indicative of him being a bad OC.

You’re clueless !
 
That has to be one of the all time dumbest statements ever made on this site. By your standards Rees at 12-0 isn‘t as good as the OC who goes 0-12


You know nothing about football

On one hand you tell us that Reese’s 21-4 record isn’t indicative of him being a good OC, and then on the other hand yo say that a 7-3 record is indicative of him being a bad OC.

You’re clueless !
When someone is as dense and ill informed as you there is no point trying to educate - only thing left is to medicate. Heavily

You must be one of those woke jokes.
 
Rees did or Notre Dame did?
You can’t have it both ways, you can’t deny Rees credit when things were good and then blame him when things are bad !

Try being objective for a change !
 
When someone is as dense and ill informed as you there is no point trying to educate - only thing left is to medicate. Heavily

You must be one of those woke jokes.
Well, you’re wrong again, really wrong …… as usual.
 
Well, you’re wrong again, really wrong …… as usual.
Not realizing that Brian Kelly dictates and installs the offense everywhere he goes, from Cincinnati to Notre Dame to LSU, and hires OC’s to run his offense, that’s a you problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chitown11
Hey Patrica, I hope you can come up and see me this Saturday. Have you ever been to ND? It’s in Indiana.
 
Hey Patrica, I hope you can come up and see me this Saturday. Have you ever been to ND? It’s in Indiana.
I spent four great years there !

Just remember what Indiana State Trooper Tim McCarthy said at so many Notre Dame games, “Don’t drink and drive !”
 
I spent four great years there !

Just remember what Indiana State Trooper Tim McCarthy said at so many Notre Dame games, “Don’t drink and drive !”
It’s nice to see a mentally challenged individual like yourself can use a computer.
 
I spent four great years there !

Just remember what Indiana State Trooper Tim McCarthy said at so many Notre Dame games, “Don’t drink and drive !”
You see no we can all see what a liar you are because there is no way in hell you went to ND. Ha ha.
 
You see no we can all see what a liar you are because there is no way in hell you went to ND. Ha ha.
Sorry to disappoint you, which is the last thing I want to do because that leads to more drinking, which isn’t good for you.

Freshman in Farley
Sophomore in Lyons
junior in Pangborn
Senior Off campus, 116 Varsity Drive if I remember correctly

Please get help and go to rehab.
 
Sorry to disappoint you, which is the last thing I want to do because that leads to more drinking, which isn’t good for you.

Freshman in Farley
Sophomore in Lyons
junior in Pangborn
Senior Off campus, 116 Varsity Drive if I remember correctly

Please get help and go to rehab.
By your standards winning justifies greatness. Winning alone is all you care about in measuring greatness

Well from 1933-1944 Hitler had 11 winning seasons. You must have his photos all over your Mom’s basement
 
By your standards winning justifies greatness. Winning alone is all you care about in measuring greatness

Well from 1933-1944 Hitler had 11 winning seasons. You must have his photos all over your Mom’s basement
Yup. Complete ignorance by poster. During the period of time that he is saying Rees was so good, Notre Dame was favored 75% of the time many times by a TD or more. Many others were toss ups. In the games where ND was a big dog they lost every game...badly.

Not the sign of a good oc. A sign of healthy recruiting and a schedule that broke well for ND....
 
  • Like
Reactions: theskibro
You can’t have it both ways, you can’t deny Rees credit when things were good and then blame him when things are bad !

Try being objective for a change !
You can evaluate him as a coach (position and OC) REGARDLESS of our win loss record

If we win a game 3 to 0, why would I give the offense credit?

You can evaluate each coach by how their unit performs
 
You can evaluate him as a coach (position and OC) REGARDLESS of our win loss record

If we win a game 3 to 0, why would I give the offense credit?

You can evaluate each coach by how their unit performs
“Performance” is on the players, NOT the coaches !
 
Correct.

Rees has NO ONE to turn to. And Freeman has NO ONE to turn to.

But then . . . OOPS . . . Freeman IS IN CHARGE!

How inconvenient.

But it's worse. Rees -- and I don't have the quote or source handy, but I know it was said -- argued that there was enough TALENT in the QB room to compete for an NC.

Kelly WOULD NOT HAVE AGREED, having BROUGHT IN COAN the previous year.

These guys only PARTLY know what they're doing. And when that's the case, you get what we've had THIS YEAR -- UNPREDICTABLE HIGHS AND LOWS, i.e. a A LACK OF CONSISTENCY.

Any game can go in ANY DIRECTION at ANY TIME. And we've WITNESSED it.
Both Kelly/Rees and now Rees failed to bring in elite QBs. We'll see on Minchey and Carr. But, up to this point, neither have brought in the proper level talent and developed it.
 
Rees went 21-4 in 2021 and 2020 for an 84 % winning percentage, that’s about as consistent as you can get.

You’re confusing failure to execute with play calling
How did we look when we played teams with a pulse?

In 2020 we lost to Clemson (when they were at full strength) and Alabama.

In 2021 we lost to Cincy(playoff team) and Oklahoma St(yes, that loss is on Kelly, and he probably would have gotten his ass kicked)
 
Are you really that dense or are you just a tool?
Neither, I’m just holding you accountable for your statements !

And evidently you can’t substantiate your claim
 
How did we look when we played teams with a pulse?

In 2020 we lost to Clemson (when they were at full strength) and Alabama.

In 2021 we lost to Cincy(playoff team) and Oklahoma St(yes, that loss is on Kelly, and he probably would have gotten his ass kicked)
Every team has a pulse, just look at all of the upsets this year.

EVERYBODY LOST TO CLEMSON AND ALABAMA. !
 
Yeah okay
So the play of the players is irrelevant ?

Good or bad play by the players is strictly on the coaches.

You just confirmed that which I’ve always known, YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT FOOTBALL
 
Neither, I’m just holding you accountable for your statements !

And evidently you can’t substantiate your claim
You claim to know TB Sr, so we are holding you accountable for your statement. You can’t have it both ways.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT