When Notre Dame loses their top target after their top target again and again on the recruiting trail this is the consequence it's nearly impossible to compete with teams that do secure their top targets on the recruiting trail.
What does 20 million in roster/recruiting NIL differential give you in the current landscape of college football? A 10 point advantage at a neutral site over your competition in the game for the trophy that represents winning it all
More fan pressure needs to be put on Notre Dame to step up to the plate and not allow any team to have this kind of competitive advantage over them and the only way to negate that advantage is to pony up the dollars and start competing for the best talent in the country on the recruiting trail. There's no way around it. You can't keep building a tier 2 roster and selling your fans a fake bill of goods that you're doing everything u can to compete for national titles.
I'm wondering where your POCKET PRESENCE IS.
Do you not see that in making such an EXTREME ARGUMENT, you're leaving yourself and your WOULD-BE LOGIC wide open to being SACKED?
Hasn't ND already proven that it can not only HANG WITH but also BEAT teams with MORE 5 STARS? Freeman's teams have demonstrated it TIME AND AGAIN. A number of Kelly's teams did it as well. And if a monopoly of 5-STARS is the sole criterion for making the playoffs and winning an NC, how come all of those teams that have more 5 STARS than ND either washed out of the playoffs or DIDN'T EVEN MAKE THE CUT?
Where's ALABAMA? Where's A&M? Where's LSU? Where's OU?
And how is it that it's ND THAT HAS MADE IT TO THE NC GAME?!?!
Finally, what will your argument be if ND BEATS OSU? It's possible. Or even if it's a REAL CLOSE GAME?
Frankly, I don't see the light-years separation between these 5 STAR ELITE TEAMS you describe and ND.
As for recruiting, if you don't realize BY NOW that ND works off a NARROWER POOL either because SOME PLAYERS SIMPLY DON'T QUALIFY or others SIMPLY DON'T WISH TO COME, then you're not paying attention to the way ND has operated since around 1952.
Fact is, you're making demands on an institution that DOESN'T SHARE YOUR PRIORITIES. And with all due respect, it's not CHANGING DIRECTION for YOUR benefit.
And in that sense you're being EXTREMELY UNREALISTIC. How is it that you simply can't SEE THIS? It's not ROCKET SCIENCE.
The only answer I can offer is that yours is not just a VIEWPOINT but a FIXATION. And fixations aren't based on LOGIC and REASON, but on EMOTION. Which then begs the question as to why are you so EMOTIONALLY FIXATED on trying to get ND to do something that is NOT IN ITS DNA?
What's your payoff in such a QUIXOTIC PURSUIT?