ADVERTISEMENT

Hartman or Pyne?

Grow up

I dont hate him. I dont know him

I'm giving a football opinion about him

No shit hes better than Pyne. Who wouldnt be?

Was hoping we did better in the portal

Having someone a step up from Pyne is NOT ALL THAT MATTERS

Having a QB that can compete talent wise when we play elite competition is what matters

We're going to win 8, 9 games with Hartman because hes a good QB. But can we beat the top teams with him

Thats a legit debate which rational posters can disagree and debate on
you are giving a biased attack on him is what it is
but of course gomers like you never admit it
Bottom line like I said show me where we can get someone clearly better
you can't can you?
 
you are giving a biased attack on him is what it is
but of course gomers like you never admit it
Bottom line like I said show me where we can get someone clearly better
you can't can you?
Why would I have a bias agaisnt him? I dont know him. Show me where I have a bias against him

What are you related to him? Because I have a different opinion of him than you. Who gives a shit.

I dont know who we can get. I'm not talking to QBs, I'm not recruiting them. Only our coaches would know that information

If it was me, I would have went after Leary
 
  • Like
Reactions: Telx1
Clemsons D wasn’t dominant this year but still very good overall with some very good individual talents. Hartman absolutely diced them up the last two seasons
People forget and think pyne played well va Clemson…. Dude threw for 85 yards… coaches praised him for saying hike at the right time
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fightingirish595
Why would I have a bias agaisnt him? I dont know him. Show me where I have a bias against him

What are you related to him? Because I have a different opinion of him than you. Who gives a shit.

I dont know who we can get. I'm not talking to QBs, I'm not recruiting them. Only our coaches would know that information

If it was me, I would have went after Leary
I like Leary slightly more than Hartman but gotta believe injury or $$$ concern
 
  • Like
Reactions: Telx1
I like Leary slightly more than Hartman but gotta believe injury or $$$ concern
Agreed, but I think we should all be happy if Hartman does in fact transfer to ND. He represents a really good pick up, a significant upgrade to Pyne, a ton of experience, and either a one year bridge or a great backup if Buchner wins the starting job.
 
I figured Hartman had already transferred. All this is just speculation? (Sorry I've been working the last few days)
 
Supposedly this leak was made, and released out into the internet ether, and to ND fans in particular, on very good authority. And this was not some sort of lame anonymous rumor. As in there was seemingly very good and every reason to believe it was legit. And that's how it was framed.

But I guess it could have been spurious.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: christophero
Well I think he'd be a great pick up. He's not going to win the Heisman, but he's a very solid college QB. I have friends in NC who are Duke football fans who say he's really good.
 
You take Leary over Hartman, but you take Hartman. He’s damn good. I’d take Leary because I’d rather win a playoff game than go 10-2. Just me I guess.
 
It was a ND recruiting journalist who leaked it, and supposedly he heard it first hand from a WF insider.

And I will say that it would be rather disappointing if it ended up being bullshit. So I hope it's not, I'm looking forward to SH. But it's Christmas, so come next week is when we should be looking for confirmation. And that would be a good Christmas present for ND fans, yeah???
 
  • Like
Reactions: christophero
Agreed, but I think we should all be happy if Hartman does in fact transfer to ND. He represents a really good pick up, a significant upgrade to Pyne, a ton of experience, and either a one year bridge or a great backup if Buchner wins the starting job.
Personally think there’s no way Buchner beats him out to start… Buchner needs to improve immensely to have packages more than jut garbage time
 
Personally think there’s no way Buchner beats him out to start… Buchner needs to improve immensely to have packages more than jut garbage time
Buchner has about as good a chance at beating out Hartman as Pyne does in beating out Tom Brady.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT