I just saw an ESPN show highlighting his life and football career.
First, I know he did some brutal and appalling things. While one can debate whether he was an innately evil monster or the byproduct of a tragic background, I'd like to table that for another thread.
Obviously, he was a very good back, I'd like to know if he was good enough to be ranked among the most talented of all time.
Ray Lewis said he was among the greatest he ever faced. In an Orange Bowl showdown, Lewis said that on one play he hit Phillips as directly and as hard as he ever had contact with anyone. The collision was shown on screen, Phillips absorbed getting drilled while going forward for a few yards, bounced right up, and told Lewis, "not bad," Lewis then turned to Warren Sapp and said "looks like we're in for dogfight tonight."
Nick Saban spoke of him in superlatives when Phillips rushed for over 200 yards against his MSU team, saying he he never saw a running back that gifted when he coached in the NFL.
Thus, my question is "Was he extremely talented or something even beyond that?"