ADVERTISEMENT

If Tenn played in the SEC…

FIFA is a horrible organization but they get tournament seedings and distribution correct for the most part. Sometimes a 1/2 bracket might be a bit tougher, but that is inevitable. Again, there is usually 1 group of death, just on stats...but not bad considering how large a tournament.

College football will improve. I also have no issue with the conference champion getting a 1st round bye...but yes, they then should have used rank and conference distribution. Actually, much as you and I are ok with conference champion getting a bye, that is indeed the problem...it might be better to use ranking, which should heavily use SOS.

Irony: Penn State got basically handed a path to the semifinal while OSU, Oregon, and Tennessee were handed a gauntlet.
Penn St. were big beneficiaries for sure, with this cockamamie seeding. Honestly, just ignore the first round byes with respect to conference affiliation. Just seed them purely on the power ratings and be done with it. An auto bid is sufficient.

If Tenn played in the SEC…

Agreed, the whole seeding thing was just sort of weird from the start. Getting a first round bye was not, at least in principle, that was at least arguable. That there's some reward for winning your conference. But if that's the price you're going to pay, an absurdly premature matchup of the two best teams in the country in only the 2nd round, or you might even say the 2nd part of the 1st round, then you might need to reconsider it.

I don't know if FIFA is a good model to follow, don't they do like a lottery, and they just draw names out of a hat? Yeah, it's weighted, so you don't get Brazil, Germany, England and Italy in the same group. And you actually could get all those teams in the same group, depending on where they finished in their qualifying groups. If I understand correctly, maybe I don't. But it's pretty easy to seed 12 games in a tolerably competitive fashion. Super easy in fact. The tricky part is the first round bye, and if you think that should be reserved for conference champs. And maybe you could re-seed them after the first weekend is in the books.


FIFA is a horrible organization but they get tournament seedings and distribution correct for the most part. Sometimes a 1/2 bracket might be a bit tougher, but that is inevitable. Again, there is usually 1 group of death, just on stats...but not bad considering how large a tournament.

College football will improve. I also have no issue with the conference champion getting a 1st round bye...but yes, they then should have used rank and conference distribution. Actually, much as you and I are ok with conference champion getting a bye, that is indeed the problem...it might be better to use ranking, which should heavily use SOS.

Irony: Penn State got basically handed a path to the semifinal while OSU, Oregon, and Tennessee were handed a gauntlet.
  • Like
Reactions: BGI User 756

Riley Leonard or Ian Book

RL does not have big play ability? You obviously don't watch the games.
Yeah, I do watch the games, what are all his big plays? To me RL is a somewhat better version of Brandon Wimbush, if even that. And that's about it. RL is a better passer, and will make the occasional nice TD pass if we pick our spots, but he's sufficiently shitty enough that the offense has to deliberately hamstring itself, and it's up to our offensive braintrust to make sure we don't ask too much of him. Which so far they've been brilliant at.

And I'm just wondering what big plays does he make? How many 40 yard plus TD runs does he have? How is he different than Wimbush in that way, who probably had more explosive runs, and more explosive pass plays. RL happens to be accurate and reliable enough with the dink and dunk stuff that you can use him for that, and the pass game can still be productive. And that was Wimbush's problem, he couldn't hit the easy passes. But he could make beautiful long bombs and downfield throws, aka 'explosive plays'. And he was probably a better runner than RL.

Offense Needs to Step Up

Georgia lost their starting QB. Yes Mills is a huge loss but Georgia losing their starting QB is a much bigger adjustment.
We've lost

Mills
Traore
Botelho
Onye
Morrison
Mickey
Jagusah
Craig
KVA - Questionable
Spindler - Questionable

Mills is the 4th DL we lost for the year. That's hard to overcome. It's not a Mills v Beck debate. It's a whats more important DL depth or a up and down QB

Also, Georgia will have had 3 weeks to adjust

Rylie Mills

Marcus Freeman. Tough one. We are really getting beat up on the Defense. Gonna be an even tougher game now. Rylie was playing his best ball -- feel terrible for the guy, he was moving up the draft board.
Unfortunate. Such a violent, physical sport. Honestly I'm surprised there aren't more significant injuries. No team is immune. Next man up. That's all you can do.
  • Like
Reactions: Classic Irish

Offense Needs to Step Up

With Mills out, our offense needs to take some pressure off the D.

Georgia is a monster challenge but they have to step up and take their game to the next level.

It all starts on our OL. They need to give us a chance. Then RL and the wrs need to make some plays. No drops. No turnovers. Faison needs to continue his accent. Collins needs to get his mojo back. Evans needs to play better

Challenge is high but we can still get it done
Georgia lost their starting QB. Yes Mills is a huge loss but Georgia losing their starting QB is a much bigger adjustment.
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT