I’m sorry. But it has to be asked
- By Vimes
- The Insider Lounge
- 31 Replies
This is premium content. Please subscribe to view.
Agree. That was a touch foulIf the refs are going to call the foul against Alloco on the 3 by NC, they need to call the foul on Burton's drive. You can't call one and not the other.
I wouldnt say the best but they are pretty damn good. I know you don't like him but I love Gus with FOXHe is the best. Knows it is about the game and not the announcers. Think him and McElroy are the best in the business.
Golden YES, not a fan of Denbrock. His playcalling against GA was baffling. Never attacked the perimeter like he should have, every outside run had 5-7 yards but he continued to run the F ing ball up middle. Did he even watch the GA Tech-GA game?With Al Golden and Mike Denbrock...Marcus Freeman has been catapulted into the higher echelon. Had he not had these two guys....he may eventually get to where ND is.....but not as quickly. His shrewd personnel skills are what I am highlighting as a head coach. And, he lets them do their job...something Kelly struggled with. Kelly wrestled for control...then shifted blame when things didn't go well.
Agreed. Even if Bauman or Sherwood aren't as good at blocking as Flanagan. If they are the 3rd TE in the game. They'll likely be on a wing or in a FB type role going against a LB or a DB creating a more favorable matchup. This does hurt, but I think ND can survive it.They both have experience in previous seasons though. Both way better blockers than Raridon who has really struggled in that aspect this year in my opinion. Who's giving the grades you saw ? Coaches grades are the only ones that matter and only ones that are accurate.
Id love to play for a coach like Markus. Ryan Day.....not so muchThis tracks with my assessment. To be honest, I'm more of an SEC guy than a CFB guy. My exposure to non-SEC teams comes around bowl season every year and scattered highlights during the season, so I typically don't form strong opinions until at least paying attention to a whole game...
But one of my key assessments lies in watching a guy as a communicator. Does he handle himself with confidence or flash signs of insecurity? Does he speak clearly and sharply or stutter through basic responses? This stuff matters when you're trying to lead a group of 85 hard asses. Was very impressed with his demeanor, confidence, and sideline presence throughout.
I'd contrast this with someone like Ryan Day who I think is a total dope, but who has NIL funds deeper than anyone but maybe Texas and can buy talent every year. Politics and money aside, Freeman strikes me as a great coach.
Appreciate your comments. I agree ND is at a disadvantage with requiring their kids go to school and actually apply themselves. However, I don't think ND needs 25 5 star players to win the NC. If we can just get 2-3 5 star guys per class at the most important positions, I'm confident ND can win. What's so frustrating that consistently ND has had the most 4 stars in the nation. They're so close. But hey maybe this year they'll shock the world!Overall the new normal benefits ND in narrowing the talent gap. You rightfully mentioned retaining the best players. And ND gets or develops NFL caliber players. Fine tuning with older proven graduate transfers in key positions.
This is breeding success. Which will attract more so called 5 stars. Again, players like Price, Love, Mills, and some OL are around 5 stars anyway.
I maintain MF is a better coach than BK. But he’s not get much farther of this change hasn’t occurred. The talent gap vs the elite was bigger.
Now Alabama, Georgia, LSU, and so can’t stack with comparatively larger but in absolute terms lower amounts of money. A car or few grand don’t suffice anymore. Blue blood northern schools and Texas have much more. Including ND, who can also more consistently get the smart NFL players who used to go to Duke, Stanford, and so.
My only concern is an Ohio State. Full bore pro that might start getting older players who don’t need study at all. ND cannot do that…but like I said, maybe ND still gets the critical mass of talent to beat that kind of team.
It was a great day when the arrogant BK d-bag left ND! Marcus is doing a wonderful job, great post Green KoolaideI have been all in on Marcus Freeman since Day 1. Many here were not, but he has done a wonderful job of convincing even the most diehard skeptics. Not all, mind you, but most. There was a large contingent of ND fans that thought it was a huge mistake hiring a young coach with no previous head coaching experience of any kind, let alone college head coaching experience. Many feared it would be Gerry Faust Act II--a nice guy in over his head.
For me, there was something intangible about Freeman that just resonated with me from the very beginning. His likeability, for lack of a better term. His authentic nature, which is rooted in humility. His work ethic. How the team embraced him when he was announced as the new HC. How important his parents and family are to him. How he understands Notre Dame and doesn't complain about its challenges, but instead welcomes those challenges, and indeed embraces them. This has given rise to his mantra, "choose hard." How he has sought out former players and brought them back to campus after previous coaching regimes didn't give those players the time of day. Joe Montana--a legend at Notre Dame--hadn't stepped foot on campus for years. Why was that? But Montana has spoken in glowing terms about MF and has since been a regular figure at many big ND games. How MF has sought out current and former coaches for advice, including beloved figures like Lou Holtz. How he has shown up to support other ND sports programs and coaches--he has been a regular figure at WBB games and for the last 2 men's lacrosse championships, and I imagine there are many other athletic programs he has supported. How he has become a part of the fabric of the university and become such an important spokesman and representative. You listen to MF give interviews, and he just oozes class. Indeed, Marcus Freeman is almost too good to be true.
I think maybe what I like most about Marcus Freeman is that he isn't afraid of failure and is confident and secure enough about himself to know what he doesn't know. I don't think Freeman is necessarily a brilliant X's and O's guy, but he has become a much better game day coach and has surrounded himself with excellent coordinators and assistant coaches who are also good men. Freeman knows how to motivate his team, and this year has certainly proven that. It would have been easy to throw in the towel after the disaster of NIU and all the season ending injuries we have experienced, but here we are in the CFB semifinals. We have gotten here because Marcus Freeman is a leader of men that his team wants to follow and to go into battle for. Those kinds of coaches don't come around very often.
Faith is believing in someone or something when you don't have a concrete reason to do so. I am happy to say, Marcus Freeman has fully rewarded my faith in him. I am now in my seventh decade, and could not be more excited about where I see the Notre Dame football program going. It was a dark day for many ND fans--but certainly not for all--when Brian Kelly chose to leave ND for LSU, but what a remarkable turn of events has transpired since then.
Go Irish!
He is the best. Knows it is about the game and not the announcers. Think him and McElroy are the best in the business.Sean McDonough is as dull as an overused butcher knife also! But we'll be hearing his pleasant voice next Thursday night again.
Really? So in your book he's now #2 in the country behind Kirby Smart? Wow, that's rarefied air. Select company. And what a thrill for MF, I hope he sees this thread. He'd be very flattered...I haven't paid close attention to ND since he took over, but I'm completely sold on that man as a coach after last night:
Strong game plan, put his guys in position, inspired them to play 60 mins, and out-coached us while thinking on his feet in the final moments.
But the sticking point was watching his body language and demeanor throughout the contest and in the handful of in-game interviews. You can tell that guy has a strong, sharp mind, and a fiery competitive edge that infects his team.
I've got nothing but confidence in Kirby going forward, but Freeman is #2 on my list of college coaches now. Impressive.
Congrats!
OK but still better then Fowler and Homer HerbieMcElroy is fine, McDonough is a toolbox
Dude, you were down on the dude, just like a few weeks ago. Pretty much all season, and he had so much to prove, like one of his most consistent, grudging detractors, and he just hadn't shown you enough. And now you're gushing and rhapsodizing. I guess he passed the test with you, huh? No offense to this UGA fan, but this was a pretty mediocre UGA team by recent standards. And fortune was very kind to us as far as the way we manufactured points and got our margin of victory. I think MF's awesome, and he couldn't be any more ideal for ND, but I don't really know what to say because our defense carries the team and I tend to put more/most of that on Al Golden, who truly was an inspired hire IMO and we look like an NFL defense. But as far as like, 'crowning' him or something, I guess I'll leave that to you.I capitulated after the NIU loss that he was in over his head and would learn on the job for years. I however always supported keeping him and trusting in the long term process, even if I considered hiring a former coordinator a failed gambit.
But he gradually recovered. With a learning curve exceeding what I thought possible. As I posted elsewhere, most importantly he seemed to impart the right amount of authoritarianism. Yet still commanding loyalty and inspiration.
Not seen this since Holtz.
No shit! WGAFF about this conversation. Just beat Ped St. Period!!Can’t we all just get along??