Yawning...
I don't know, maybe because Phil smashed about every record in PA in HS. 4000 yards passing, 78% comp with 40 TD's and only 6 ints and averaged 248 yards passing/game and 1200 yards rushing at 9.2 yards per carry? Or maybe, just maybe, it was because he was a high 4 star top 100 player with offers from Alabama, Clemson, and other top schools? Book was a low 3 star with NO other big offers other than ND. I still think Phil's upside is way more than Books. Sadly we will probably never find out. At least at ND anyway.
Funniest thing you've said since April 2019...
Everything you say is funny and stupid. I always laugh at your nonsense. Sometimes it gets annoying but it's always a good laugh for a known troll. Get over your obsession with Kelly.
I've never once called any poster a name on here.
Except when the opponent is good and the game is a big one.
LMAO, you had to go dust off this login to just troll me? 309 post in 9 years? How pathetic is that? So how many logins do you you have? Bodi?
I don't remember that, unless it was under someother login, which wouldn't suprise me. I mean you are quite different and the ultimate homer. I think a lot of us long time posters just have accepted that about you. But whatever floats your boat.
I know, all you've done is call a Notre Dame player a coward. That was beyonddd embarrassing. You're a clown and I'll call you on it.
Ssshhh!!!
#1
I dont care what you say. So you shouldnt when I call you out for what you are. A troll and clown. Stop b*tching about name calling you soft liberal
That's rich.
Im not upset. Why do you seem so offended when I call you a troll and clown. Dont get so offended. You're dishing "cold hard facts" on our players. And I'm doing the same to you. Stop being so soft and defensive.
easy there keyboard giant. After reading these posts, it's pretty apparent that you're the one going after 88ND, not the other way around. 88ND is simply providing his opinion on Kelly and Book, which I agree with, and you don't like it. Some of us would prefer to see ND at least be competitive in major bowl games. Kelly is an above average coach, but he appears to have hit his ceiling, and continues to prove over and over that he is NOT some QB wizard. Not to mention, with the talent ND recruits every year, the players don't appear to be getting all that much better. While there are additional coaches on ND's staff, at the end of the day, if the players don't improve and win, it's on Kelly. Period.
It's non stop bashing Kelly in every post when it is warranted and when it is not. Then calling our quarterback a coward crossed the line. So im going to call him out when he's wrong. If He has every right to say what he said. Thats fine. It got annoying but I'm not upset. Then he shouldnt be upset when I call him out to what I feel he is. I have no problem. He can call out Kelly and the players. And im going to call him out. Dont be so sensitive sticking up for him
I see your point. I'm not so much sticking up for him as I just agree with how Kelly has "coached" the qb position. Having a talent like PJ sitting on the sidelines when we are up by 3 TDs with 8mins left seems a little ridiculous. The kid continues to get very little real time game experience. Kelly has been here for 9 or 10 seasons, and the QB play has been average at best overall. That is on whomever is "coaching" the QBs or the head coach.
Calling PJ a scrub is a bit harsh. The kid is far from a scrub, but for whatever reason isn't able to beat out Book, who is possibly the worst Power5 QB at throwing the deep ball...and that's likely not even debatable.
Phil is no pioneer in this situation.
I agree with your point and wish Kelly would let Phil play a lot more actually. I wouldn't even be against a change as stater. But the non stop complaining and bashing and taking over every thread by him is ridiculous
Book is a major player in college football landscape and Phil is a scrub? Please.... Not slamming Book but that praise is unwarranted. Book isn't even on the top 20 watch list for the Heisman. He's a average to good qb and that's it. He's an improved Reese 2.0.
I'm not sure who said that but I personally don't believe Book is afraid of contact considering how much he runs. I think the biggest reason he flushes from the pocket easily is his height. I think when the pocket gets tight he cannot see his recievers over 6'3 and taller lineman when you're barely 6'.
The real lack of productivity from Book, in being able to exploit the deep secondary means that we probably won't run up enough points to have PJ ever get meaningful snaps. Even in blowout wins, PJ played actually very little. He has never been put in a situation where he has to perform, meaning that if he ever came off the bench, he prob would fail, thys supporting BKs prophecies PJ isn't ready
I agree. I also don't think he's comfortable or confident going through his progressions which leads to his happy feet. He ran over that USC defender last year. Afraid of contact is crap and lazy
LMAO, was this a serious post? With one series you say Phil sucks and has no future? Oh and for Michigan game PJ was 75% completion and 1 TD. Book was 31% and only one TD and played almost the entire game. Do you even follow ND football?
I know I was being a big hard on the Beaver but really? I mean I really hope I just missed the sarcasm on that post but I think it was and he was serious.
