Well, can't say about that ND fans and any former players that rise to that level in the broadcasting/punditry world. Our fans long, and pine for an ex-player to take over for our home games, which are national broadcasts, I guess because they can't stand, whoever it is, Doug Flutie, anybody who betrays even the slightest hidden animus for ND, however illusory or not it may be. Maybe that's why you don't care for Herbie, because he has to be dispassionate, and can't show favoritism. And blah, blah, blah he never shuts up even though it's his job to talk.
That would be funny if he was all laconic and barely spoke. And there was like, long silent stretches. Herbie, you still there?? But with modern technology, you just tune into your local homer radio feed, and mute your TV. And ND's is pretty awesome. With Ryan Harris, he's great.