Buchner sadly is toast
- Thread starter theskibro
- Start date
You fail. Fail. All those names you list. Maybe a total of 6 games were started by one or two of them. Since you all so full of crap, Huarte was not inherited by Ara. Ara made him a QB. Ara n Lou got the most out of their players. They developed them. They brought new ones in. Essentially you are saying that the names I listed is an incomplete list and that they were not anything special. You are wrong on both counts. It’s a complete list of every qb that started for these 2 coaches except for Andrysak and one other game. You obviously like to joust and call people out on facts
This time you tried so hard to defend your point it’s comical and it’s wrong. Everyone makes mistakes. You would have more cred if you owned up instead of manufacturing bs
2 Guys in 12 years.
Kizer only lasted 2 years. 11td 24ints
Book is fighting to stay in the league. 0tds 2ints
Thats pathetic
It’s a shame you dropped out of high school, or was it grade school? It really is. Life’s to short to be as dumb as you!
You’re clueless, Ara didn’t develop Huarte, he inherited him from Kuharich/Devore.
Every one of those names I listed were never developed by Ara and Lou into outstanding QB’s.
I didn’t manufacture anything, everyone of those QB’s were QB’s under Ara and Lou.
And everyone of them were never developed into outstanding QB’s by Ara and Lou.
Why do you think that Ara and Lou failed to develop those QB’s ?
You’re clueless !
Let’s see, I entered Notre Dame as a chemical engineering major, how about you ?
And I graduated in four years, how about you ?
You’re beyond obtuse !
If they were recruited by Ara and Lou, Ara and Lou must have been high on their ability to play QB at ND and not be “nobodies” as you declared.
So why did Ara and Lou fail to develop them into outstanding QB’s ?
You can’t have it both ways, you can’t give Ara and Lou a pass for not developing outstanding QB’s !
They didn't make an impact and I believe are now free agents. The point is it's been a LONG time since ND had a very good QB, never mind one who had a decent chance in the NFL. I go back to Quinn and Clausen, under Weis.
CBK never got nor developed QBs good enough. Recruiting was an issue, something I'm hoping Freeman can maybe change bit. Hartman is here...maybe given the changes and my thinking about Freeman charisma, the next Andrew Luck or somebody similar comes.
Anyways, I've got noting against CBK. As I keep posting, I wish him well and appreciate what he did.
In cherry picked clips he looked that way
For one season
ITs not surprising so many coaches did not look beyond that; or beyond his physical gifts.
NFL GMs have done the same year after year. Look at all the big armed busts taken in the first rd.
For one season
ITs not surprising so many coaches did not look beyond that; or beyond his physical gifts.
NFL GMs have done the same year after year. Look at all the big armed busts taken in the first rd.
I don't know. I think if you had God the Father as head coach and he got the Holy Spirit to run his offense and his kid to be our defensive coach, we might have a shot.
Seriously, so much of you say is true. I think if Freeman fails, he will go into the Faust file, where people will remember him for his love for the university and forgive his coaching shortcomings.
I understand BK didn't make the schedules but neither did Lou. ND played harder schedules back in the day. Also didn't have training tables & turf. I'm very happy that I saw ND in the era. Special time.
College Football is so drastically changed since Lou, it's virtually impossible to compare then and now. With portal and NIL, CFB is effectively minor league professional football, with damn near nothing about it being college; maybe just the team names.
You can if you’re so smart and so well educated that you don’t need to finish high school !
I understand that your best years in high school were the three years you spent as a sophomore !
Calling you a colossal moron is extremely insulting to morons !
Coaches putting their Quarterbacks in position to fail. Asking them to do stuff they can’t do
It ain't coaching at all, these kids just aren't that good. The interception by Milrose was absolutely ridiculous; that ain't coaching
It ain't on Rees, Alabama is simply not that good. Their OLine stinks, QB room is shit and they RBs are average at best. Rees has been there 6 months, and you wanna blame him? Seriously? Milroes INT was a HS mistake, that ain't on the coach.
Said it on here after the Marshall game last year that he wasn't any good and many stans came to his defense.
Bottom line was pretty much trading him for Hartman was a genius move on Freeman's part and might end up keeping Notre Dame in the playoff convo all year while Bama struggles to win 9 games.
Bottom line was pretty much trading him for Hartman was a genius move on Freeman's part and might end up keeping Notre Dame in the playoff convo all year while Bama struggles to win 9 games.
Rees is in a perfect storm. The Tide don’t have the players they once did. Especially QBs.
We always harp on talent mattering most. Heck it’s been the bane of ND football wrt winning a NC. That said…Rees is also learning in rough waters.
Again, perfect storm for him.
We always harp on talent mattering most. Heck it’s been the bane of ND football wrt winning a NC. That said…Rees is also learning in rough waters.
Again, perfect storm for him.
Amazing so the narrative is that Rees left ND for Bama and doesn’t have the talent to work with to show off his QB development super powers. Ok, got it.
And you think he's gonna "develop" QBs in 6 months. Any idea how stupid that sounds? Christ. Your narrative is one of hating Tommy Rees, that at least is pretty clear.
Yes he can have a QB1 that was a top 50 recruit ready to play. But when has he ever had a QB ready to play. He does have the kicker and punter looking ready though.
Get a clue man, you are giving the Alabama OC a pass due to not having the talent to score TDs vs USF.
Dante Moore 7 of 22 with a INT and Fumble in the Red Zone; guess it's the OCs fault for not getting this high recruit ready to play.
Alabama #1 (by a mile) in recruit class rankings over last 5 years. UCLA #36. Please tell me you have something more than a talent gap. Done with this discussion. The last word is yours. Go Irish.
You were telling me about how in 6 months he should be able to "develop " a high recruit ready for play, and you told me to get a clue. Oh how the narrative changes when your shown to be wrong. But you're entitled to live in your own world and your own narrative. Yup, go Irish
Yeah I'm gonna blame him. He has five stars across the line and gets no push. The defense is lined up Everytime like they know the play...because he doesn't change his calling scheme. The next time he develops improvement in any quarterback will be the first.
It's absolute nonsense that people are defending Rees because of the talent level at bama. The talent at bama is much better than what was at ND last year... much better. Yet they look horrid.. yeah that's on the oc and the play caller.
No it's not, 5 TDs called back because of penalty. Ridiculous INT in the Red Zone. His "play calling" should have accounted for 38 points against the #15 team in the country. Develop? Please .. he's been there for 8 months. You hate him, I get it. Nothing he did for us (averaging over 30 points a game) was ever good enough, and now your narrative is set.
