Selection Committee
- Thread starter Pennick4
- Start date
If you hate everything about what team sports is about sure.
Here is my problem....
How do you know? I hear a lot of "I think" about Bama and FSU. FSU went out and won ALL games.
No they did not -- FSU EARNED their right to compete in the playoff --
This committee simply did not want to see the SEC shut out.
Agree they got it right, but if were interviewing Boo Coorigan right now I would ask if he believe Georgia is the 6th best team today
FSU would get blown out by any of the other teams in playoff
Yet another year why, as I've said from day 1, the playoff should've been more than 4 teams.
There are ALWAYS going to be more than 4 teams that "deserve" to play for the championship of a sport.
Not a job I would want, but I would've picked Alabama too. No way FSU would beat them. And that will essentially be proven when Georgia beats them by 2+ TD's. You have to talk about context in a situation where 1 team is undefeated and 1 has 1 loss on this level. I know a lot of you just blindly hate the SEC no matter what and it clouds your judgement, but the reality is what it is.
There are ALWAYS going to be more than 4 teams that "deserve" to play for the championship of a sport.
Not a job I would want, but I would've picked Alabama too. No way FSU would beat them. And that will essentially be proven when Georgia beats them by 2+ TD's. You have to talk about context in a situation where 1 team is undefeated and 1 has 1 loss on this level. I know a lot of you just blindly hate the SEC no matter what and it clouds your judgement, but the reality is what it is.
What makes you think that? They beat Auburn and Arkansas by a field goal, USF by 14.
I think, i think, i think.
I also heard no way Washington beats Oregon (double digit dogs).
I'm not saying you are wrong... all I am saying is nobody knows. It's ALL speculation. What's not speculation is one team from a major conference went undefeated, the other lost a game.
They stink without their starting QB. Best 4 teams are in.
Then why even play the season if your one injury away from being left out.
You are arguing that they should change the criteria from best team to the most deserving team (and I agree that should be the criteria).
There will never be agreement with who the best 4 teams are (is Georgia the 6th best team?).
There would be less controversy if the criteria were most deserving (I think all agree FSu is amongst the 4 most deserving)
Because its the four best teams DUH. If Travis doesn't get hurt then FSU would be in. Without him, they are done. Its an injury on a QB, not a DL or LB or RB. If Mccarthy got hurt, michigan wouldn't have made it. Whats so hard to understand? fsu stinks without Travis
OMG, most deserving? LMFAO, thats like saying "johnny you did great" and everyone gets a trophy. Its the BEST TEAMS hello
Lol I noticed his hairline is all the way up half of his scalp at this point dude needs to just shave it off already
I watched an FSU defense play better defense than everyone that played Friday and Saturday. No one is mentioning that. Their defensive line just absolutely dominated.
The SEC is an Auburn defensive coordinator blunder away from being left out of the playoffs.
The SEC is an Auburn defensive coordinator blunder away from being left out of the playoffs.
Georgia might very well blow out FSU in bowl game. Depends on who sits out the bowl game.
So I assume the committee in its fairness will put FSU back in if one of the other four playoff team's quarterbacks injures himself in a practice leading up to the game? That's what so ridiculous in how they made their decision. Did FSU's offense look weak with a freshman QB last night, yes it did, but wouldn't they have a month of preparation with their now healthy backup QB to get ready for the game?
It's a really bad look for the NCAA but with NIL and the open door transfer portal, it's almost to be expected now. Listening to the guy try to explain it and then Chris Fowler basically slobbering over his "expertise" was pathetic.
Last edited:
That's what they are saying now. But they were always going to move the goalposts for the sec. Healthy jordan Travis I think they still get passed by.
No the way they won 12 facing the # 5 toughest schedule in the country.
