ADVERTISEMENT

PSU vs BSU

Ole Miss, Alabama, and Miami should have all had playoff spots over Boise, SMU, and ASU

Boise and ASU aren't even in the top 20 in F+ and both got first round byes and both are likely going to get rocked (ASU butt kicking coming tmw)

I don't have an issue with conference champions getting in. The seeding and byes were however a terrible idea. SOS should factor in tweaking rankings.

That said, a point I've made all season: the last 4 of a 12 team playoff will always have some margin of error. Be in that top 8 and avoid these margins.

Lastly, I'm NOW unsure Ole Miss, Alabama, and Miami would have done better.
 
Yawn.

Go drink another beer:

Read what I have written about Jeanty.

I could not be more complimentary about him.
All I read is nonsense, excuse me for not keeping up with your 300 posts a day..think about posting less and attempting some quality. Your lack of anything outside this board is evident. New Year’s resolution perhaps- find a hobby
 
  • Haha
Reactions: NotreDomer1
I’d rather have Allen or Singleton before Jeanty. Not impressed at all. He’s a little guy
 
I don't have an issue with conference champions getting in. The seeding and byes were however a terrible idea. SOS should factor in tweaking rankings.

That said, a point I've made all season: the last 4 of a 12 team playoff will always have some margin of error. Be in that top 8 and avoid these margins.

Lastly, I'm NOW unsure Ole Miss, Alabama, and Miami would have done better.
I watched Penn State lose at home to Ohio State and get beat by Oregon.

Many teams could beat them. Just not Boise.
 
All I read is nonsense, excuse me for not keeping up with your 300 posts a day..think about posting less and attempting some quality. Your lack of anything outside this board is evident. New Year’s resolution perhaps- find a hobby
Gee. OK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZibbyQuinn
I’d rather have Allen or Singleton before Jeanty. Not impressed at all. He’s a little guy
Watch the NFL Draft in April.

Smarter people than you will answer that question.

He’s far better than what you say here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Get Nasty
Boise state played hard. too many mistakes and couldn't overcome them against PSU. PSU made them pay.
 
PSU should have their 2's and 3's in at this point. Dumb risking injury
 
I don't have an issue with conference champions getting in. The seeding and byes were however a terrible idea. SOS should factor in tweaking rankings.

That said, a point I've made all season: the last 4 of a 12 team playoff will always have some margin of error. Be in that top 8 and avoid these margins.

Lastly, I'm NOW unsure Ole Miss, Alabama, and Miami would have done better.
Why should the conference champion get in if the record is mediocre at best?

Aren’t the 12 best team supposed to be selected ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NDinNJ
Ole Miss, Alabama, and Miami should have all had playoff spots over Boise, SMU, and ASU

Boise and ASU aren't even in the top 20 in F+ and both got first round byes and both are likely going to get rocked (ASU butt kicking coming tmw)
Wrong. Would have had similar results.
 
Lastly, I'm NOW unsure Ole Miss, Alabama, and Miami would have done better.
One bowl game performance with much of the two deep gutted doesn't outweigh the other 12 games of performance with these programs' full rosters intact
 
  • Haha
Reactions: NDinNJ
One bowl game performance with much of the two deep gutted doesn't outweigh the other 12 games of performance with these programs' full rosters intact
Alabama lost 3 games 2 against Oklahoma, Vanderbilt with their full roster. oklahoma who lost to Navy. Put the crack pipe down.
 
Alabama lost 3 games 2 against Oklahoma, Vanderbilt with their full roster. oklahoma who lost to Navy. Put the crack pipe down.
And Clemson couldn’t beat South Carolina at home. 0-3 against the SEC.

But Dabo did win the shitty ACC.
 
And Clemson couldn’t beat South Carolina at home. 0-3 against the SEC.

But Dabo did win the shitty ACC.
So none of them belonged. Alabama, SC, Ole Miss, Miami didn't belong period. We would have had similar round 1 results, so who got in is a moot point.
 
So none of them belonged. Alabama, SC, Ole Miss, Miami didn't belong period. We would have had similar round 1 results, so who got in is a moot point.
After Ohio State, Oregon, Notre Dame, Georgia, Texas, and Penn State, I am not certain it matters anyways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NDinNJ
After Ohio State, Oregon, Notre Dame, Georgia, Texas, and Penn State, I am not certain it matters anyways.
After this group it would be a bunch of really good SEC teams:

Alabama
Ole Miss
SOUTH Carolina
Tennessee

Along with Miami and their full offense intact.
 
Why should the conference champion get in if the record is mediocre at best?

Aren’t the 12 best team supposed to be selected ?


I explained how you can basically get the best 8 in, with 4 being a margin of error.

And its would be unusual to be a conference champion yet have a mediocre record...kinda like comparing strengths across NFL divisions.

It takes a balance of record, SOS, conference champion, and, especially, ranking.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT