Yes we will, I feel Hartman is much more accurate than book on throws over 5-10 yards.
Hartman deep ball in practice
- Thread starter edub72
- Start date
Agreed. I was gonna say he was about 2 yds short of it being an indefensible pass. Hair splitting season is upon us.
Do you think Hartman compares more to Jack Coan? When he was on at ND, Coan ripped defenses up with intermediate passes without ever being a running threat? I love T Buck but also look forward having a legit passer under Center. That’ll be a welcome change.
You are comparing a 5th year player going into a 6th year to a 2nd year going on to his 3rd year. Buchner's upside is higher than Hartman. Hartman isn't going to get much better than he's been.
Buchner had one legitimate receiver to throw to last season and he was a tight end. So please stop comparing apples to oranges.
Not buchner lol
Not meant to be a dig, but in reality it's simple. Hartman can make consistent accurate passes, buchner can not.
Sam Hartman is quite a bit older than Tyler Buchner as well.
Tyler Buchner is one snap away from the 2023 starting job, and IMO will win the starting QB job at Notre Dame for the 2024 season.
Lol. Hartman is going into his 6th year. He'll be at the pro day next year
What did you expect someone else to be out there. Lol
Maybe Minchey too right haha
You could see it in his face when he said it. He wasn’t bs’ing.
He wouldn’t do great things here if Mayer thought Buchner was on the same level.
He wouldn’t do great things here if Mayer thought Buchner was on the same level.
Writing incessant disparaging comments about a 20-year-old second year QB at Notre Dame could be described in other ways as well.
He is odds favorite to win it now but I’d think he would need to show immense improvement with his opportunities this year
You are as dumb as a rock. You do realize ND is giving this to Hartman because it gives him a chance to showcase his skills to scouts in his final year in college. You are just a dummy.
There no way he has coaches full trust to make the right decisions in the pass game
I do not see TB ever being the starting QB at Notre Dame unless the MULTIPLE GUYS ahead of him all get injured or flunk out or steal cars.
This is his third season; practice and everything else has not shown much improvement from when he got here.
I do not see him improving enough to be the starter baring other happenings.
This is his third season; practice and everything else has not shown much improvement from when he got here.
I do not see him improving enough to be the starter baring other happenings.
Hartman pushes the ball way more than Coan did, and has much better pocket presence.
What do you expect him to say, "Yea he's going to be an average QB, lucky to be able to win the starting job"?
I could see it now if Hartman doesn't live up to your lofty expectations. You'll be blaming the OC, QB coach, Freeman 😂
I don’t see hate but more so reservations…. That’s fine, I’m bullish
We didn’t have a qb last year who had a clue in the passing game. We have probably a top 5 passing qb in the college game now
No hate, just being realistic. He's not elite, if he was, he would have went pro, but instead he opted for a 6th year. That's the reality.
