Fair enough. I know a few ND gradates. Most agree ND could do what I described without compromising the academic brand and, most importantly, achieve a social mission.
Nobody suggesting skipping classes, cheating, or empty degrees. I choose my words carefully: a remedial but progressive degree. Yes, it's tailored to the athlete who couldn't keep up in a regular degree.
I wrote on another thread how my Catholic all boy HS had tier 1, 2, and 3 (honors) classes to accommodate a range of abilities. It worked out very well, with most being accepted to college. This could be adopted so ND gets the best athletic talent...as do OSU, AL, and GA, where I think most graduate now.
Mind you, I'm fine with ND staying the way it is. I'm a Catholic subway fan with memories of the 70s and 80s. But younger fans might not stay so loyal, as winning matters. Always has. Always will.
Football helped make ND. Why not keep up such a tradition and brand? Again, I don't see any compromise chasing this as I described.
BTW: I work in hi-tech in Silicon Valley. With talented STEM folks from all kinds of universities. Including ND, the Ivies, SEC schools, community and state schools.
Do you think top software engineers from USC, AL, Wisconsin, or OR came from prostituted schools? Because of what they do in their sports programs? Really?
I hope you see my point.