ADVERTISEMENT

247Sports: Notre Dame Is An Overrated Team Heading Into 2023

I disagree. And that writer also has Miami as an underrated team. Miami hasn't proven anything yet. Last year, they started out #16 and finished 5-7.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BGI User 756
Wow. Great rebuttal. ND fans are lucky to have an assassin like Brian Driskell advocating our position. He completely decimated 247’s argument.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: chaseball
I’d say 9-3 is totally acceptable for Freeman and everyone should be happy for him for that. The admin has done next to nothing to support him. He can’t hire who he wants. He can’t get the admin to support NIL measures that make us competitive. We don’t spend money on facilities to match the top programs. We haven’t won a single big bowl game in 30 years.

Marcus had 3 5 star players committed and lost them at the end. A QB, safety, and Vyper, all who would have contributed this year but they bolted bc the admin isn’t interested in winning. This could potentially happen every single year. Cam and CJ will get offered mega bags after they show out their senior years. They might be more invested. Let’s hope so. Maybe they stay maybe they go. If they bolt, Freeman will then revert to BK era RKG stuff. Most likely, Freeman will be at Ohio State before long, where he’s able to get support needed to win a championship. Until then he will grind in recruiting within the archaic regulations and win as many games as he can. Then he will get the promotion to OSU.

If Jack retires, we could see Freeman get the support he needs to get back to winning.
 
Last edited:
I’d say 9-3 is totally acceptable for Freeman and everyone should be happy for him for that. The admin has done next to nothing to support him. He can’t hire who he wants. He can’t get the admin to support NIL measures that make us competitive. We don’t spend money on facilities to match the top programs. We haven’t won a single big bowl game in 30 years.

Marcus had 3 5 star players committed and lost them at the end. A QB, safety, and Vyper, all who would have contributed this year but they bolted bc the admin isn’t interested in winning. This will potentially happen every single year. Cam and CJ will get offered mega bags after they show out their senior years. Maybe they stay maybe they go. If they bolt, Freeman will then revert to BK era RKG stuff. Most likely, Freeman will be at Ohio State before long, where he’s able to get support needed to win a championship. Until then he will grind in recruiting within the archaic regulations and win as many games as he can. Then he will get the promotion to OSU.
Now don’t go throwing out that truth serum to the board. They will accuse you of being Chase’s clone and tell you ND isn’t that far away…forgetting that in 2024 with a new playoff system ND would have to beat 4 top 12 teams in a row to win the Natty. Not likely. So you’ll be told to just follow another team or get off the board altogether. Still not addressing the root cause of the problem which is the administration and JS. Until those things get fixed (which they won’t) you might consider pulling out that 1988 tape against West Virginia to remind you of what it was like to win the big one!
 
  • Like
Reactions: IrishBeer
Now don’t go throwing out that truth serum to the board. They will accuse you of being Chase’s clone and tell you ND isn’t that far away…forgetting that in 2024 with a new playoff system ND would have to beat 4 top 12 teams in a row to win the Natty. Not likely. So you’ll be told to just follow another team or get off the board altogether. Still not addressing the root cause of the problem which is the administration and JS. Until those things get fixed (which they won’t) you might consider pulling out that 1988 tape against West Virginia to remind you of what it was like to win the big one!
Our best odds is to follow the Clemson model. Recruit 10’ish level and get the top QB. Dante Moore comes to mind. Then, hope he pans out to be Trever Lawrence. But we lost him over money and then we lost the OC over money and then lost the guy Freeman wanted to replace that OC with over money.. We then hired a horrible OC candidate for reputation and elite QB reciting and luckily still have CJ. But I don’t see this OC landing the top overall QB in 2025 and I don’t see us finishing inside the top 5 until Jack is gone. Either consistently land to 5 classes or get the #1 overall QB. Doing neither isn’t going to do shit.
 
I’d say 9-3 is totally acceptable for Freeman and everyone should be happy for him for that. The admin has done next to nothing to support him. He can’t hire who he wants. He can’t get the admin to support NIL measures that make us competitive. We don’t spend money on facilities to match the top programs. We haven’t won a single big bowl game in 30 years.

Marcus had 3 5 star players committed and lost them at the end. A QB, safety, and Vyper, all who would have contributed this year but they bolted bc the admin isn’t interested in winning. This could potentially happen every single year. Cam and CJ will get offered mega bags after they show out their senior years. They might be more invested. Let’s hope so. Maybe they stay maybe they go. If they bolt, Freeman will then revert to BK era RKG stuff. Most likely, Freeman will be at Ohio State before long, where he’s able to get support needed to win a championship. Until then he will grind in recruiting within the archaic regulations and win as many games as he can. Then he will get the promotion to OSU.

If Jack retires, we could see Freeman get the support he needs to get back to winning.
Yawn.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Kelso86
I disagree. And that writer also has Miami as an underrated team. Miami hasn't proven anything yet. Last year, they started out #16 and finished 5-7.
ND is a competitor for the final 4. ND will be a top 10 team at the seasons end. Get behind ND!
 
Our best odds is to follow the Clemson model. Recruit 10’ish level and get the top QB. Dante Moore comes to mind. Then, hope he pans out to be Trever Lawrence. But we lost him over money and then we lost the OC over money and then lost the guy Freeman wanted to replace that OC with over money.. We then hired a horrible OC candidate for reputation and elite QB reciting and luckily still have CJ. But I don’t see this OC landing the top overall QB in 2025 and I don’t see us finishing inside the top 5 until Jack is gone. Either consistently land to 5 classes or get the #1 overall QB. Doing neither isn’t going to do shit.
1. We have a QB coach now that will be the draw to qbs...and that's a good thing
2. You honestly know nothing about the oc. How do I know? Because no one does. He's never called his own offense. I think it's fair to say "unproven oc" but you can't say horrible knowing he's never ran the ship.
3. He wasn't hired for reputation, he was hired because he is on the same page and has a preexisting relationship with the school and the hc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbone3114
1. We have a QB coach now that will be the draw to qbs...and that's a good thing
2. You honestly know nothing about the oc. How do I know? Because no one does. He's never called his own offense. I think it's fair to say "unproven oc" but you can't say horrible knowing he's never ran the ship.
3. He wasn't hired for reputation, he was hired because he is on the same page and has a preexisting relationship with the school and the hc.
I’m also an unproven offensive coordinator. Should they have hired me?
 
I’m also an unproven offensive coordinator. Should they have hired me?
Go apply to be a head coach and run your own D1 program since you are so good at being a couch critic.

"It's not the critic who counts, not the man who points out that the strong man stumbles..."
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Kelso86
Go apply to be a head coach and run your own D1 program since you are so good at being a couch critic.

"It's not the critic who counts, not the man who points out that the strong man stumbles..."
Everyone wins in your world. They also wear tuck it bathing suits from Target.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Chitown11
I’d say 9-3 is totally acceptable for Freeman and everyone should be happy for him for that. The admin has done next to nothing to support him. He can’t hire who he wants. He can’t get the admin to support NIL measures that make us competitive. We don’t spend money on facilities to match the top programs. We haven’t won a single big bowl game in 30 years. He had 3 5 star players committed and lost them at the end. A QB, safety, and Vyper, all who would have contributed this year but they bolted bc the admin isn’t interested in winning. This will potentially happen every single year or freeman will revert to BK RKG stuff. Most likely, Freeman will be at Ohio State before long, where he’s able to get support needed to win a championship. Until then he will grind in recruiting within the archaic regulations and win as many games as he can. Then he will get the promotion to OSU.
I’d say 9-3 is totally acceptable for Freeman and everyone should be happy for him for that. The admin has done next to nothing to support him. He can’t hire who he wants. He can’t get the admin to support NIL measures that make us competitive. We don’t spend money on facilities to match the top programs. We haven’t won a single big bowl game in 30 years.

Marcus had 3 5 star players committed and lost them at the end. A QB, safety, and Vyper, all who would have contributed this year but they bolted bc the admin isn’t interested in winning. This could potentially happen every single year. Cam and CJ will get offered mega bags after they show out their senior years. They might be more invested. Let’s hope so. Maybe they stay maybe they go. If they bolt, Freeman will then revert to BK era RKG stuff. Most likely, Freeman will be at Ohio State before long, where he’s able to get support needed to win a championship. Until then he will grind in recruiting within the archaic regulations and win as many games as he can. Then he will get the promotion to OSU.

If Jack retires, we could see Freeman get the support he needs to get back to winning.
a bunch of this is total nonsense. 9-3 is the floor this year for cmf , talent alone only OSU is clearly better. he got his 2 mulligans last year. Admin has loosened up academics far more then what Weiss, Davie, Ty had to deal with. So I think admin clearly wants to win. In terms of hiring, he doesn’t have the Rolodex so what established stud coordinator says I’ll roll the dice on my career with an unproven HC? Details on Utah oc not totally clear and it seems realistic to believe he just like being in Utah more. Our facilities are top 10 in the country so that’s not an issue. Yeah he didn’t close on some difference makers but I‘m not sure that happens every year. We’re leading or at the top for Lambaert, Rushing and Scott. Why do you think he ends up at OSU before long? Seems he still has a lot to prove. And what specifically are the archaic regulations? Admissions has been loosened, we have nil, we took 10 guys this year via the portal. What exactly do you want?
 
The only reason I am fine with “loosening” academics is bc they already bend them to a pathetic degree. The fact that Tae Johnson is visiting is proof. ND’s football team has 0 players that could ever in a million years get admitted to the school without football. The average undergraduate student vs a ND football player is so vastly different in academic achievement it’s a totally different universe. I’m not worried about academics. They don’t make it hard to get in if they’re good at football

My issue with not caring about hiring the best coaches coaches, worrying about pinching pennys, not building the best facilities, resisting any and all change that is best for kids until it’s too late to be of any benefit. They always eventually do things. They just like to be last. They don’t support freeman. The losses are on Jack. He doesn’t have his OC. He got burned on multiple recruits.
 
  • Like
Reactions: baron100
The only reason I am fine with “loosening” academics is bc they already bend them to a pathetic degree. The fact that Tae Johnson is visiting is proof. ND’s football team has 0 players that could ever in a million years get admitted to the school without football. The average undergraduate student vs a ND football player is so vastly different in academic achievement it’s a totally different universe. I’m not worried about academics. They don’t make it hard to get in if they’re good at football

My issue with not caring about hiring the best coaches coaches, worrying about pinching pennys, not building the best facilities, resisting any and all change that is best for kids until it’s too late to be of any benefit. They always eventually do things. They just like to be last. They don’t support freeman. The losses are on Jack. He doesn’t have his OC. He got burned on multiple recruits.
The first paragraph.... you do not know that
 
The first paragraph.... you do not know that
If you have even the slightest idea how difficult it is to get into ND you know my statement isn’t just a fact, it is common sense. Our football players do not have a 4.1 gpa and 99th percentile SAT scores. That’s literally a fact. Also, ND has the same statistics for admissions as Harvard, but we admit fewer. ND is harder to get into than Harvard. ND’s football players are all extremely average run of the mill kids academically. Many have 3.0 or less.
 
Last edited:
The only reason I am fine with “loosening” academics is bc they already bend them to a pathetic degree. The fact that Tae Johnson is visiting is proof. ND’s football team has 0 players that could ever in a million years get admitted to the school without football. The average undergraduate student vs a ND football player is so vastly different in academic achievement it’s a totally different universe. I’m not worried about academics. They don’t make it hard to get in if they’re good at football

My issue with not caring about hiring the best coaches coaches, worrying about pinching pennys, not building the best facilities, resisting any and all change that is best for kids until it’s too late to be of any benefit. They always eventually do things. They just like to be last. They don’t support freeman. The losses are on Jack. He doesn’t have his OC. He got burned on multiple recruits.
Garbage.
 
If you have even the slightest idea how difficult it is to get into ND you know my statement isn’t just a fact, it is common sense. Our football players do not have a 4.1 gpa and 99th percentile SAT scores. That’s literally a fact. Also, ND has the same statistics for admissions as Harvard, but we admit fewer. ND is harder to get into than Harvard. ND’s football players are all extremely average run of the mill kids academically. Many have 3.0 or less.
There are certainly some players who would be able to get into Notre Dame. Not many but for you to act like it's zero is incorrect. If you say it's a fact, prove it. Share their SAT scores along with their gpa. The fact is you cannot. You do not know

There are plenty of kids who have 4.0 gpas plus from high school. I've seen them talk about it. I ha e no idea their sat scores but you are wrong
 
There are certainly some players who would be able to get into Notre Dame. Not many but for you to act like it's zero is incorrect. If you say it's a fact, prove it. Share their SAT scores along with their gpa. The fact is you cannot. You do not know

There are plenty of kids who have 4.0 gpas plus from high school. I've seen them talk about it. I ha e no idea their sat scores but you are wrong
I am 100% certain the vast majority of our players do not have a 4.1 AND a 99th percentile SAT. Please.

Is there definitely not someone? IDK. But if so it’s probably 1.
 
Last edited:
I am 100% certain the vast majority of our players do not have a 4.1 AND a 99th percentile SAT. Please.

Is there definitely not someone? IDK. But if so it’s probably 1.
You said none. Remember that?

And like I said, prove it
 
I am 100% certain the vast majority of our players do not have a 4.1 AND a 99th percentile SAT. Please.

Is there definitely not someone? IDK. But if so it’s probably 1.
Please post the last 5 recruiting classes individual GPA's and SAT/ACT scores.
 
You don’t have to prove it moron. They offer a boatload of the top 100 recruits.
What does being a top 100 recruit mean? They are all morons? Do you have the grades or scores yet?

Prove it or shut the hell up about it. Because you don't know
 
You only have 200 more to go.

Prove it
You’re a dip shit. You are the only person dumb enough to think that all of our football players have a 4.1 gpa and 1500 SAT or 32 ACT. Literally you’re that dumb.
 

Jerimiah Love.....4.1 gpa top 100 recruit lol

And there is more
You’re naming the exception, not the rule. That also doesn’t mean they had a 1500 SAT, which is way more difficult. NONE of these players would get in without football. It doesn’t make them dumb. It means they let in kids that wouldn’t otherwise get in. I rest my case.

“Of Notre Dame's 13 commits that are ranked in the Top 100, ten are at 3.4 or better. One of the three players is defensive end Boubacar Traore, whose GPA we weren't able to obtain. Traore, however, attends an outstanding private school in Massachusetts.

Notre Dame's best recruit in the 2023 class is Tampa (Fla.) Berkeley Prep star defensive end Keon Keeley, who is a five-star recruit and the No. 3 player in the country according to On3. The Berkeley star racked up an astounding 34 tackles for loss and 16.5 sacks as a junior. Keeley carries a 3.45 GPA. He's truly an elite student-athlete.

Denton (Texas) Guyer safety Peyton Bowen is yet another five-star recruit, and he ranks as the nation's No. 18 overall player according to On3. Bowen is a brilliant football player, picking off seven passes as a junior, but he's also a 3.45student that plans to major in business with a desire to be an entrepreneur when his playing career comes to a close.


Notre Dame went into the Buckeye State to land Mentor (Ohio) High School defensive end Brenan Vernon, who chose the Irish over Ohio State. Vernon ranks as the nation's No. 23 overall player according to Rivals. He has also earned 3.25 GPA in the classroom.

St. Louis (Mo.) DeSmet Jesuit cornerback Christian Gray is also one of the nation's best players, ranking No. 51 overall according to Rivals, and he picked the Irish over LSU and Ohio State. Gray is a 3.3student who wants to major in sports journalism.

Irvington (N.J.) High School safety Adon Shuler is another consensus four-star recruit that ranks as the No. 170 overall player in the land, and he's an outstanding student. Shuler has earned a 3.3 GPA and is a member of the National Honor Society.

Notre Dame recently landed Derby (Kan.) High School star Dylan Edwards, who rushed for 2,603 yards and 38 touchdowns as a junior. He also recently rank a sub-4.4 at the Future50 event and ranks as the nation's No. 234 overall player, and he sports an impressive 3.3GPA.

Lake Stevens (Wash.) High School running back Jayden Limar rushed for 1,549 yards and 20 touchdowns last season, and he's the No. 247 overall player in the country according to 247Sports. He is also a 3.4student that wants to major in business and possibly minor in real estate at Notre Dame.

Tight end Cooper Flanagan plays for one of the country's best high school teams at Concord (Calif.) De La Salle, and he's one of the nation's best tight ends, ranking as the No. 123 overall player in the country. Oh, and he's a 3.5 student that also wants to major in business.”
 
Last edited:
Our kids are smarter than the average college football player but to pretend that most are in the same universe as the general ND population is really naive and just factually false. There are always a few that probably would.
 
You’re naming the exception, not the rule. That also doesn’t mean they had a 1500 SAT, which is way more difficult. NONE of these players would get in without football. It doesn’t make them dumb. It means they let in kids that wouldn’t otherwise get in. I rest my case.

“Of Notre Dame's 13 commits that are ranked in the Top 100, ten are at 3.4 or better. One of the three players is defensive end Boubacar Traore, whose GPA we weren't able to obtain. Traore, however, attends an outstanding private school in Massachusetts.

Notre Dame's best recruit in the 2023 class is Tampa (Fla.) Berkeley Prep star defensive end Keon Keeley, who is a five-star recruit and the No. 3 player in the country according to On3. The Berkeley star racked up an astounding 34 tackles for loss and 16.5 sacks as a junior. Keeley carries a 3.45 GPA. He's truly an elite student-athlete.

Denton (Texas) Guyer safety Peyton Bowen is yet another five-star recruit, and he ranks as the nation's No. 18 overall player according to On3. Bowen is a brilliant football player, picking off seven passes as a junior, but he's also a 3.45student that plans to major in business with a desire to be an entrepreneur when his playing career comes to a close.


Notre Dame went into the Buckeye State to land Mentor (Ohio) High School defensive end Brenan Vernon, who chose the Irish over Ohio State. Vernon ranks as the nation's No. 23 overall player according to Rivals. He has also earned 3.25 GPA in the classroom.

St. Louis (Mo.) DeSmet Jesuit cornerback Christian Gray is also one of the nation's best players, ranking No. 51 overall according to Rivals, and he picked the Irish over LSU and Ohio State. Gray is a 3.3student who wants to major in sports journalism.”
You said no one. That is ridiculous. So prove it. No shit they let players in that wouldn't normally get in. What are you an idiot.

10 of the 13 had 3.4 or higher. How much higher and what about the rest?

You make an idiotic statement that none of them could get in, then prove it. You said none have a 4.0 well Love had a 4.1. And there were others as well. I dont know his sat and either do you. Proving my point
 
You said no one. That is ridiculous. So prove it. No shit they let players in that wouldn't normally get in. What are you an idiot.

10 of the 13 had 3.4 or higher. How much higher and what about the rest?

You make an idiotic statement that none of them could get in, then prove it. You said none have a 4.0 well Love had a 4.1. And there were others as well. I dont know his sat and either do you. Proving my point
I said 4.1 and SAT scores. SAT is much harder. I already conceded that there could be some. Most no way and there’s proof. There’s no proof that Love had a 1500 SAT. Maybe he did. But it doesn’t change the fact that most would never get in. My original premise is we already bend the rules so the talk about how we won’t bend academic rules is bs. We do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: baron100
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT