Hey Perse. I've stayed away from everything ND football on purpose for months now and it's helped me gain a different perspective.
BK has made plenty of mistakes but honestly even if he was perfect it would take ND never having any injuries or players leaving (their choice or not) for ND to ever compete with the likes of Bama or O$U. Meyer and Saban don't have to be perfect because they have enormous advantages in recruiting and training players.
Those schools can recruit any player they want. ND has to take a lot of project players because they simply can't offer most of the elite players. Players at those schools are semi-pro and spend most of their time on football, ND players spend most of their time on school.
So unless a season (like '12) comes along where there are very few injuries and we get every break imaginable I can't see ND really competing for a NC. Win 9-11 games per season and I'm happy with that. I'm no longer going to be upset at a stupid mistake because I realize nobody is perfect and perfect is what it's really going to take for ND to really compete.
Graduate your players (with real degrees), keep them out of trouble and win 9+ games a season and I'm a happy camper.
Good post.
I understand ND's criteria and thus their limitations in recruiting.
What I don't understand (someone please explain) is things like:
1. Not having a Division One training table (hell, ANY training table) until a few years back.
While ostensibly everyone else in College Football gave importance to diet, nutrition and training, the Irish were out at BK (not Brian Kelly, Burger King) scarfing down 2 Whoppers, two fries, and a diet coke on a regular basis. How does that ever happen?
2. From what I hear, although it has gotten better, is laziness/miscommunication in recruiting happened all too often.
You are right, we do have such a substantially smaller pool to choose from; therefore
you can never get outworked on the recruiting trail...... you simply can't afford to.
3. There is still an animosity from the academic side (although not as public anymore) towards the football team..... as if these people are embarrassed that ND should have a good football program, that it somehow takes away from Notre Dame's academic reputation, a therory which is myopic, inaccurate and pretentious BS.... see Stanford.
4. The self implosion in head coaching hires, and/or AD's...... no excuse.
I LOVE ND, always will,and believe we are trending upward, but you can't tell me a good portion of the last 20 years of mediocrity isn't self created.
GO IRISH!