So What Does Hartman Do?
- Thread starter Notre Dame du Lac
- Start date
He was outstanding for both teams!
Hartman comes to ND, ignores anything TR calls, and rewrites the passing record book at ND for a season.
He has to see that he is light years ahead of anyone we have on campus right now.
He looks for a NIL/Bag deal and takes it.
He might be worried about regression under TR s tutelage!
Hartman wins the job easily. Buchner is a good change of pace.. with the ability to surprise you with a throw over the top. Jmo
Nope.
But I can now see Buchner being the guy
3 warm up games before OSU, I play whoever you think has more potential to win by game 4
10 months of practice and 3 more games.....maybe Buchner
Thing is, even IF Buchner somehow starts over Hartman he is almost guaranteed to get injured at some point. Even today he was taking shots. Any team with him starting needs a good backup ready to go at any second.
If you keep saying it in every forum post, it's still stupid.
It's more of a competition than most on this board want to admit for sure
He comes to ND and starts..
no more 2-3 picks a game and spotting other team 14-21 points
Na he comes to ND and competes.
QB room suddenly goes from zero to hero after Buchners nice showing tonight.
You got a #165 overall prospect coming in who is really polished, you got a potential Ian Book-like tweener in Hartman who is battle tested and experienced but maybe lacks upside, and then you got Buchner, a gifted high 4-star prospect who is getting better and better it seems.
Will be interesting to follow the QB battle all off-season. We're going to need multiple QBs if Buchner wins the job.
edit: Minchey is the #165 prospect, not a top 150 prospect my bad
Last edited:
nice showing
what a a crock
But then from a Uscum fan like you, you want a turnover machine as the ND QB.
He played in the ACC; not a mid major. He would be a huge upgrade and would make us preseason top 10.
Great game from TB, it really was. But hardly the transcendent performance to somehow queer the deal with Sam Hartman at the last minute. Assuming of course that it's all ready to roll and an announcement is forthcoming and imminent.
I will say that the thought of TB the athlete and running QB is so enticing. He'd be like our version of Jayden Daniels....
I will say that the thought of TB the athlete and running QB is so enticing. He'd be like our version of Jayden Daniels....
Hartman is a solid player in a solid system responsible for putting up big numbers, etc. and he'll be a nice addition to fall camp for sure. But Tyler Buchner has a whole other level of upside to his game if everything clicks.
Hes going to come. But hes not going to have an easy time winning the job
The offense was much more dynamic with Buchner than Pyne. So imagine if a way more polished passer is pulling the trigger. I’m not a big Buchner fan. If NDwsnts to go 9-3 he’s the guy. But he is not a playoff caliber guy. Hartman has a higher floor.
Agreed. But Buchner has the higher ceiling
Do you want to play it safe or possibly go for it
Either guy should get ND to 3-0 going into the 9/23 matchup with OSU. Buchner if and it’s a big if can become a more disciplined passer and mitigate interceptions, he definitely has a higher ceiling IMO. You can see his potential and the potential for the O if he’s playing well the run game and passing game will be very hard to stop due to his abilities in both facets (if improved passing).
The majority of the top teams seem to have a guy that can hurt you with their feet as well as their arm.
Last edited:
This is how I feel
Because of that 3 game stretch, I want Buchner to win the job. He'll have 3 games to get ready and get experience. If things are clicking, the offense will be more dangerous with him at QB
IF EVERYTHING CLICKS WHICH IT NEVER HAS BEFORE
The delusion of some here about TB is awesome
The worst thing to happen to him would be to start- the fan base would tear him apart after enough Pick 6's
WHICH HE CLEARLY would have a lot of
like the Williams kid, but maybe a less accurate and less arm strength; but he has that dimension. And he looks like a freakin choir boy!
TB’s 3rd game, fellas. Keep some perspec… oh nvm it’s game day and we’re talking QB 1 at Notre Dame; there’s never any perspective in either situation.
Btw I 100% and have always been supportive of Tyler as the starting QB. He’s tough as frrrr as a runner and will only get better as a passer.
Btw I 100% and have always been supportive of Tyler as the starting QB. He’s tough as frrrr as a runner and will only get better as a passer.
Similar threads
