Id have to see that pylon view. If definitely right about incontrovertible evidence and I agree there. Im just confused why the best angle to judge it was the only angle not shown on the broadcast. It’s reckless by ESPN to say the least. Can you link the pylon view?
Let me be the 1st one to congratulate Michigan
- Thread starter rivals50
- Start date
Id have to see that pylon view. If definitely right about incontrovertible evidence and I agree there. Im just confused why the best angle to judge it was the only angle not shown on the broadcast. It’s reckless by ESPN to say the least. Can you link the pylon view?
They should just rename it to the hard hit penalty.
We should stop whining about calls in the lol Michigan thread.
The pylon view is probably the worst view.
I don’t know why they don’t show the frontal view which shows the ball being bobbled.
At this point it doesn’t matter, but the whole point of replay is to get the play right, and that’s more important than our biased views as fans..
What surprised me was how poor the resolution was on the South Carolina receivers foot on the called TD pass yesterday
I don’t know why they don’t show the frontal view which shows the ball being bobbled.
At this point it doesn’t matter, but the whole point of replay is to get the play right, and that’s more important than our biased views as fans..
What surprised me was how poor the resolution was on the South Carolina receivers foot on the called TD pass yesterday
Yeah, but that’s still the wrong camera to judge. Why in the heck is the pylon camera unavailable? It was used later in the game so I know it’s there.
It’s not the worst view. It’s the absolute best view for what transpired.
You’re definitely right about the SC cameras. I haven’t seen such terrible camera closeups in over a decade that I can remember. The SC WR was kicking up white chalk. That wasn’t from the end zone. Out. BUT, because the camera view was so damn piss poor, there wasn’t a real way to call it other than what was ruled.
You’re right. There’s definitely not enough evidence to overturn what was called on the field based on that.
Which takes me back to the FSU game and the alleged pick call and the failure to call a penalty on the FSU player for taking off his helmet.
In theory, video replay has a secondary benefit of preventing “homer calls”, so as fans, even if a video replay doesn’t favor ND, I want the video replay to get it right. That’s why the video crew has to be from a different conference than the field crew.
To avoid errors and ”homer calls” the NFL has all replays reviewed from league headquarters because the NFL wants to get the call right, regardless of which team it favors
In theory, video replay has a secondary benefit of preventing “homer calls”, so as fans, even if a video replay doesn’t favor ND, I want the video replay to get it right. That’s why the video crew has to be from a different conference than the field crew.
To avoid errors and ”homer calls” the NFL has all replays reviewed from league headquarters because the NFL wants to get the call right, regardless of which team it favors
That’s not at all what he said. He said it was short of the end zone.
I agree with this, but the NFL has botched a ton of roughing the passer calls this year. They’re definitely not a beacon of consistency IMO.
That’s because RTP is such a subjective call, whereas calls of fact, ie, he is or isn’t out of bounds, aren’t so subjective.
But they’re working on improving the replay process. More cameras/angles are part of the improvement process
I thought we are the Michigan haters. This is a ND board right
Hate them or not, you have to give Harbaugh credit,
Harbaugh took a troubled program and got them into the NC Playoffs !
“Clown” ?
You’re the clown, he’s a highly successful coach, in both the NFL and in college.
You should be half as successful in your vocation as he’s been in his vocation !
....I assume you will be having dinner with Harbaugh sometime this week....
HOF thread here imo
I could give a flying fvck whether Michigan deserved to win etc.
Michigan lost, which to an honest world is roughly the equivalent of Iran Russia etc losing
I could give a flying fvck whether Michigan deserved to win etc.
Michigan lost, which to an honest world is roughly the equivalent of Iran Russia etc losing
I've been called moron by far more knowledgable and respectable posters than yourself.
Then it’s unanimous, you’re a total and undisputed moron as determined by knowledgeable and respected posters.
But, I didn’t call you a moron !
I didn’t call you a moron because you’re too stupid to be a moron !
Try to understand the difference !
Last edited:
That’s what all the good looking young women say !
Do you think it’s pretty being easy ?
Similar threads
