With all the bemoaning and aching for older, purer times, the success that these three, all of whom will be drafted by the NFL, speaks to why the transfer portal is a good thing in many ways. In the old system, you could have a player who is talented but things don’t go exactly right in a hyper competitive environment and the player gets stuck in the doghouse, doesn’t develop, and then never realizes his potential. Yes, they were able to transfer, but the penalty for doing so was quite severe, i.e., sitting out a year.
Bo Nix was never thought of as a strong NFL candidate. Jayden Daniels was never thought of an NFL quarterback. Michael pennix had hope, but not as a top 10 nfl draft pick. It makes me think about all the players who have played in the past who might’ve had different outcomes if they were allowed a change of scenery for whatever reasons.
It’s also a boon for players who are destined to be recruited over and stuck behind other players for reasons not always under their control.
You are right about that. And lest my previous posts be misunderstood, I am not one of those who thinks the portal or NIL are bad things, they just make the game different from what we have been accustomed to for decades, and they have brought some breathtaking (and as some will argue, long overdue) changes to the college football game. As regards the portal, I agree with you that it may allow a kid who might sit on the bench to see if there are greener pastures somewhere else. And that is not necessarily a bad thing, though I suppose that an unintended consequence is that it may leave the school that a player transfers from with an unplanned hole in its roster. ND is seeing that with the WR position, and given our historical reluctance to accept non-graduate transfers, it has put us in a little bit of a bind, though some of those wounds are self-inflicted. But ND will live to fight another day.