Freeman Rules Out Transfer QB

[IrishBeer]

 

[Golson5]

Old news

 

[Holycrossover3]

As a backup for this year? Or was the question phrased for the 2024 season?

I figured his answer would be the same for both at this point. Can’t risk more QBs transferring out.

 

[Golson5]

As a backup for this year? Or was the question phrased for the 2024 season?

I figured his answer would be the same for both at this point. Can’t risk more QBs transferring out.

This year

 

[IrishBeer]

He’s talking about 2024

 

[Chitown11]

This year

LOL, 2024 dummy

 

[scubastevefl]

Minchey and Angeli need to worry more about Carr than a transfer for 24.

 

[NDDadx3]

LOL, 2024 dummy

Nope. Listen to his presser. He said he’s happy with Angelli as the #2 and that’s why he didn’t being in another QB via the portal.

 

[Golson5]

LOL, 2024 dummy

Wrong dummy. You think hed be making proclamations about 24 before the 23 season??

Use your limited brain.

What a dope

 

[Holycrossover3]

Minchey and Angeli need to worry more about Carr than a transfer for 24.

You have to be really special in todays era to start a freshman at QB for a blue chip school.

Even many of the elite guys like Trevor Lawrence didn’t start the opener. Maybe we’ll see Carr start to mix in early but I’ll be truly flabbergasted if he’s starting @A&M.

If history is repeating itself, we’re much more comfortable going into the transfer portal than starting a freshman. We haven’t since 2010.

 

[ftnfan62]

In 2024, you have a 3-star senior and a 4-star sophomore. I think MF must use 2023 to get extended time for those two. Not victory formation, the entire fourth quarter when you're up 28. If they look the part in real games, no need to bring in a xfer. If they look lost, you would be stupid not to go after a blue chip proven QB. It killed you in 22. Who cares if one of those 2 xfer if you're banking on CJ.

 

[Holycrossover3]

In 2024, you have a 3-star senior and a 4-star sophomore. I think MF must use 2023 to get extended time for those two. Not victory formation, the entire fourth quarter when you're up 28. If they look the part in real games, no need to bring in a xfer. If they look lost, you would be stupid not to go after a blue chip proven QB. It killed you in 22. Who cares if one of those 2 xfer if you're banking on CJ.

I agree with you here. I do have a question though.

Just for fun, let’s say Minchey looks pretty solid in mop up duty this year. Certainly good enough to start in 2024. But, there’s a blue chip transfer who we could get, and for that one year, he would technically be better than Minchey, but Minchey is younger, so longer runway.

Who do you go for? How much better does the 1 year player need to be to go the transfer route? If they’re close in production you should always go younger, but if you go with the transfer you’re potentially opening up the door for the younger recruit to leave.

Modern day dilemmas I guess.

 

[IrishMike409]

I agree with you here. I do have a question though.

Just for fun, let’s say Minchey looks pretty solid in mop up duty this year. Certainly good enough to start in 2024. But, there’s a blue chip transfer who we could get, and for that one year, he would technically be better than Minchey, but Minchey is younger, so longer runway.

Who do you go for? How much better does the 1 year player need to be to go the transfer route? If they’re close in production you should always go younger, but if you go with the transfer you’re potentially opening up the door for the younger recruit to leave.

Modern day dilemmas I guess.

That’ll be a tough scenario. No idea what MF would decide to do.

Minchey would begin his career @A&M. Won’t be easy.

Likely a new offensive line too…..

 

[sjb75]

As a backup for this year? Or was the question phrased for the 2024 season?

I figured his answer would be the same for both at this point. Can’t risk more QBs transferring out.

Why would you ask about 2024 in July?

 

[sjb75]

Wrong dummy. You think hed be making proclamations about 24 before the 23 season??

Use your limited brain.

What a dope

For the same reason this poster did.

 

[Holycrossover3]

Why would you ask about 2024 in July?

To be honest idk who would be recruiting a transfer QB end of July, especially during camp.

 

[sjb75]

I agree with you here. I do have a question though.

Just for fun, let’s say Minchey looks pretty solid in mop up duty this year. Certainly good enough to start in 2024. But, there’s a blue chip transfer who we could get, and for that one year, he would technically be better than Minchey, but Minchey is younger, so longer runway.

Who do you go for? How much better does the 1 year player need to be to go the transfer route? If they’re close in production you should always go younger, but if you go with the transfer you’re potentially opening up the door for the younger recruit to leave.

Modern day dilemmas I guess.

IMO Steve Angeli will have first crack at mop up duty.

 

[Holycrossover3]

IMO Steve Angeli will have first crack at mop up duty.

I know. My scenario was more so to include a younger QB playing well Vs an older transfer.

 

[sjb75]

I know. My scenario was more so to include a younger QB playing well Vs an older transfer.

Marcus Freeman has 4 months to figure out if Angeli or Minchey are good enough to win at TAM.

 

[Holycrossover3]

Marcus Freeman has 4 months to figure out if Angeli or Minchey are good enough to win at TAM.

Thank you.