CFP committee vs the F+ Top 12

[chaseball]

Just me or does the top 12 in F+ look like a legit playoff with the best ~12 or so teams in the country vs that of the CFP playoff committee's top 12? I'd be way more interested in seeing how F+'s tournament bracket would play out than that of the official CFP committee's top 12/playoff bracket this year.

I feel like too many good teams are being penalized too severely for losses in really competitive games vs really competitive conference opponents and its going to start incentivizing programs to schedule more watered down seasons vs crap opponents to pad the W-L record and avoid potential losses on the final record.

PS I apologize for the poor formatting, just did some quick copy and paste jobs to get the information in one place.

CFP Top 12
1 Oregon 9-0
2 Ohio State 7-1
3 Georgia 7-1
4 Miami 9-0
5 Texas 7-1
6 Penn State 7-1
7 Tennessee 7-1
8 Indiana 9-0
9 BYU 8-0
10 Notre Dame 7-1
11 Alabama 6-2
12 Boise State 7-1

vs

	F+ Top 12
1​	Ohio State	2.26​
2​	Oregon	2.19​
3​	Georgia	2.02​
4​	Ole Miss	2​
5​	Texas	2​
6​	Alabama	1.89​
7​	Miami	1.69​
8​	Penn State	1.68​
9​	Notre Dame	1.67​
10​	Tennessee	1.62​
11​	Indiana	1.57​
12​	LSU	1.45​

 

[chaseball]

BTW I feel like the CFP committee will have a good idea of who the best teams are by the end of the regular season (so this isn't really a knock on the CFP committee perse), but I think F+ is a bit ahead of the CFP committee in figuring out who the best teams are, which is why the current Top 12 in F+ in week 10 is a good idea of what the final CFP committee's top 12 might look like by the end of the season.

 

[Pennick4]

More flatulence from Chase and his buds ..😂

 

[mrwigglesby21]

Replacing BYU and Boise St with Ole Miss and LSU seems logical. Unfortunately BYU is the defacto Big 12 Champ, and Boise the G5 champ. So it is what it is. Also makes the SEC regular season more valuable for those participants.

 

[Golson5]

BTW I feel like the CFP committee will have a good idea of who the best teams are by the end of the regular season (so this isn't really a knock on the CFP committee perse), but I think F+ is a bit ahead of the CFP committee in figuring out who the best teams are, which is why the current Top 12 in F+ in week 10 is a good idea of what the final CFP committee's top 12 might look like by the end of the season.

No it won't. F+ has 6 sec teams and that's not happening. And it has no big12 or non p4

So it's not even close to what it will be in the end