I think due to multiple significant injuries he is eligeable to apply for a sixth year, but you never know. ND stated they could have played him late in the season but held back to preserve the 6th year option.
Is he better than shumate? Heck no. He's had a number of injuries and we haven't seen him on the field for nd for any extended time. Prior to injury the word seemed to be he was pretty good particularly in run support and attained the knowledge of the bvg scheme- so he would play. But better than Shumate? He had a really nice sr year, and was a strong run support safety. Probably the most consistent safeties on our roster. Which says a lot about the rest of those guys.