ADVERTISEMENT

Spring Practice Competition

Telx1

I've posted how many times?
May 13, 2012
7,293
7,728
113
This is going to be one hell of an interesting Spring for ND football. Starting positions are not necessarily decided in Spring alone, but it offers a great opportunity for players to separate from the competition. You can make an argument for multiple position fights, but the three areas that intrigue me the most are:

QB is the obvious starting point. Angeli has done everything asked of him and done it well when given the opportunity. He’s our only QB with anything close to experience. Carr shined last Spring and gets accolades galore over his poise and passing skills and commitment to constant improvement. Minchey has a great arm and superior running ability, and seems a really good fit for Denbrock’s offense. Really hope one separates from the others, but doubt it. Kind of expect this decision to be drawn out to Fall with hopes of keeping all three on the roster.

OL presents some tough decisions as well. Lambert and Craig and Knapp and Black stand out to me as the big question marks. I think Jagusah and Schrauth and Wagner are locks to start. Craig was a tremendous upgrade when he captured the center position, but he is a question mark because of his knee injury and surgery. Knapp was very good on rushing plays and average or below average on passing plays as our left tackle, but showed tremendous poise, really good skills, and excellent feet for a third string freshman thrown into the starting job a week before playing TAM. But Knapp does not have prototypical size for LT at ND, and his skills seems perfect of playing inside. The assumption is both Craig and Knapp start again this season, and if so, the only question is where Knapp plays…LT or guard, and that then determines where Jagusah plays. Under this scenario, I prefer left to right Jagusah- Knapp- Craig-Schrauth-Wagner. But is either or both Lambert and Black too good to keep off the field, and what about Absher, who is also a talented monster? I continue to think Craig is the key. If not fully recovered, I think Knapp moves to center, Lambert or Black to LT, and Jagusah to guard.

DL has so many unknowns. Out of an eight man rotation, about the only two that are locks and healthy are Young and Rubio. We know that Botelho and Traore are going to play a ton, just not sure when. Burnham and Jr were major contributors last season, but will likely find their numbers reduced by the return B and T. Does Onye return healthy and in playing shape to pair with Rubio? Does the Louisville portal transfer win that spot? Does Mukum or Dixon elevate? Where is Vernon in all of this? Can Hinish add good weight? Does Saviano earn a rotational role? Can Thomas build on his freshman resume? Does true Freshman Burgess become this year’s Young? Etc…etc….

Spring practice starts in something like twelve days, and I for one am looking forward to reading how these position battles develop, and looking forward to folks here posting what they are reading or hearing. I need my ND fix!
 
This is going to be one hell of an interesting Spring for ND football. Starting positions are not necessarily decided in Spring alone, but it offers a great opportunity for players to separate from the competition. You can make an argument for multiple position fights, but the three areas that intrigue me the most are:

QB is the obvious starting point. Angeli has done everything asked of him and done it well when given the opportunity. He’s our only QB with anything close to experience. Carr shined last Spring and gets accolades galore over his poise and passing skills and commitment to constant improvement. Minchey has a great arm and superior running ability, and seems a really good fit for Denbrock’s offense. Really hope one separates from the others, but doubt it. Kind of expect this decision to be drawn out to Fall with hopes of keeping all three on the roster.

OL presents some tough decisions as well. Lambert and Craig and Knapp and Black stand out to me as the big question marks. I think Jagusah and Schrauth and Wagner are locks to start. Craig was a tremendous upgrade when he captured the center position, but he is a question mark because of his knee injury and surgery. Knapp was very good on rushing plays and average or below average on passing plays as our left tackle, but showed tremendous poise, really good skills, and excellent feet for a third string freshman thrown into the starting job a week before playing TAM. But Knapp does not have prototypical size for LT at ND, and his skills seems perfect of playing inside. The assumption is both Craig and Knapp start again this season, and if so, the only question is where Knapp plays…LT or guard, and that then determines where Jagusah plays. Under this scenario, I prefer left to right Jagusah- Knapp- Craig-Schrauth-Wagner. But is either or both Lambert and Black too good to keep off the field, and what about Absher, who is also a talented monster? I continue to think Craig is the key. If not fully recovered, I think Knapp moves to center, Lambert or Black to LT, and Jagusah to guard.

DL has so many unknowns. Out of an eight man rotation, about the only two that are locks and healthy are Young and Rubio. We know that Botelho and Traore are going to play a ton, just not sure when. Burnham and Jr were major contributors last season, but will likely find their numbers reduced by the return B and T. Does Onye return healthy and in playing shape to pair with Rubio? Does the Louisville portal transfer win that spot? Does Mukum or Dixon elevate? Where is Vernon in all of this? Can Hinish add good weight? Does Saviano earn a rotational role? Can Thomas build on his freshman resume? Does true Freshman Burgess become this year’s Young? Etc…etc….

Spring practice starts in something like twelve days, and I for one am looking forward to reading how these position battles develop, and looking forward to folks here posting what they are reading or hearing. I need my ND fix!
Can't wait to see how the o line shakes out. Might not really know until fall camp when Craig more likely up to speed. I'm on record as saying I think Jagusah would be a bonfide All American at guard. I'd love to see left to right, Lambert,Schrauth, Craig, Jagusah and Wagner with Knapp the ideal 6th man. Lots and lots of talent in that room. It really is a no lose situation barring an inordinate amount of injuries.
 
I dont expect Black to be ready and he is a summer guy. I think the competition is between the 7 other guys you mentioned and maybe a Peter Jones also pushes inside

DL, there are 6 guys who will be in the rotation at DE and 4 of them are healthy for spring. Both Botelho and Traore will be back for fall and Botelho will apparently be full go starting in summer. Onye is full go and his issue had nothing to do with injury. The top 4 DTs in spring will be Rubio Onye Hinish and the Lou kid. All upperclassmen and all have played a lot of p4 football. The question is what other 2 interior fits can emerge and push. Dixon is injured and won't be a factor this year. Mukam the USC transfer and Sevillano probably battle to get in the rotation. Mullins Houstan and Vernon need a big spring to get on mix
 
Can't wait to see how the o line shakes out. Might not really know until fall camp when Craig more likely up to speed. I'm on record as saying I think Jagusah would be a bonfide All American at guard. I'd love to see left to right, Lambert,Schrauth, Craig, Jagusah and Wagner with Knapp the ideal 6th man. Lots and lots of talent in that room. It really is a no lose situation barring an inordinate amount of injuries.
Craig won't be practicing during the spring so hoping they give Knapp a chance there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: edub72
I am hearing that Rudolph is a big fan of Knapp at left tackle. Can't wait to hear about the battles.
 
I am hearing that Rudolph is a big fan of Knapp at left tackle. Can't wait to hear about the battles.
As I recall, Rudolph was a big fan of Knapp’s before Rudolph came to ND; and he insisted then that Knapp would play tackle and not guard in college. This was in spite of others projecting Knapp as a guard at the next level. Frankly, I hope Jagusah or Lambert or Black wins the LT spot and Rudolph moves Knapp inside. But the operative word is wins!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kelso86 and Golson5
Stubborn ? Makes no sense.
Yeah it does. He loves Knapp. He loved him as a recruit before ND. And rightfully so. But people have said (don't know ow if true maybe not) that he wants him to be the LT and isn't considering him interior. I dont think he is the best option there. I dont think you do either. And I don't think any other schools recruited him as a tackle. They recruited him as an interior guy.

Sometimes coaches really have an affinity for certain players. It happens to every coach
 
Golson5 wants us to believe he can evaluate talent better than the actual coaches. 🤣
No. Every other school recruited him as an interior guy. Were they all wrong 🤣. All you care about is personal with me. Not about reality. Not about having a discussion. It's really pathetic. I believe Harry viewed as an interior guy and didn't offer him.

So not every coach has the same opinion and the coaches aren't right on every player either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mmca
I dont expect Black to be ready and he is a summer guy. I think the competition is between the 7 other guys you mentioned and maybe a Peter Jones also pushes inside

DL, there are 6 guys who will be in the rotation at DE and 4 of them are healthy for spring. Both Botelho and Traore will be back for fall and Botelho will apparently be full go starting in summer. Onye is full go and his issue had nothing to do with injury. The top 4 DTs in spring will be Rubio Onye Hinish and the Lou kid. All upperclassmen and all have played a lot of p4 football. The question is what other 2 interior fits can emerge and push. Dixon is injured and won't be a factor this year. Mukam the USC transfer and Sevillano probably battle to get in the rotation. Mullins Houstan and Vernon need a big spring to get on mix
I don't expect black to start but wasn't ALT a summer guy. My point is I think Black could have similar trajectory to ALT BUT he probably won't be needed in 2025, maybe not even 2026 depending on wagner.
 
This is going to be one hell of an interesting Spring for ND football. Starting positions are not necessarily decided in Spring alone, but it offers a great opportunity for players to separate from the competition. You can make an argument for multiple position fights, but the three areas that intrigue me the most are:

QB is the obvious starting point. Angeli has done everything asked of him and done it well when given the opportunity. He’s our only QB with anything close to experience. Carr shined last Spring and gets accolades galore over his poise and passing skills and commitment to constant improvement. Minchey has a great arm and superior running ability, and seems a really good fit for Denbrock’s offense. Really hope one separates from the others, but doubt it. Kind of expect this decision to be drawn out to Fall with hopes of keeping all three on the roster.

OL presents some tough decisions as well. Lambert and Craig and Knapp and Black stand out to me as the big question marks. I think Jagusah and Schrauth and Wagner are locks to start. Craig was a tremendous upgrade when he captured the center position, but he is a question mark because of his knee injury and surgery. Knapp was very good on rushing plays and average or below average on passing plays as our left tackle, but showed tremendous poise, really good skills, and excellent feet for a third string freshman thrown into the starting job a week before playing TAM. But Knapp does not have prototypical size for LT at ND, and his skills seems perfect of playing inside. The assumption is both Craig and Knapp start again this season, and if so, the only question is where Knapp plays…LT or guard, and that then determines where Jagusah plays. Under this scenario, I prefer left to right Jagusah- Knapp- Craig-Schrauth-Wagner. But is either or both Lambert and Black too good to keep off the field, and what about Absher, who is also a talented monster? I continue to think Craig is the key. If not fully recovered, I think Knapp moves to center, Lambert or Black to LT, and Jagusah to guard.

DL has so many unknowns. Out of an eight man rotation, about the only two that are locks and healthy are Young and Rubio. We know that Botelho and Traore are going to play a ton, just not sure when. Burnham and Jr were major contributors last season, but will likely find their numbers reduced by the return B and T. Does Onye return healthy and in playing shape to pair with Rubio? Does the Louisville portal transfer win that spot? Does Mukum or Dixon elevate? Where is Vernon in all of this? Can Hinish add good weight? Does Saviano earn a rotational role? Can Thomas build on his freshman resume? Does true Freshman Burgess become this year’s Young? Etc…etc….

Spring practice starts in something like twelve days, and I for one am looking forward to reading how these position battles develop, and looking forward to folks here posting what they are reading or hearing. I need my ND fix!
I'm sure they'll cross train Jagusah, but I would expect we get a sense in the spring if he's practicing more at Tackle or Guard.

Does Lambert run more with the ones at LT or Jagusah? Could be telling

I'd prefer Knapp starts doing snapping training at center, I think that's his ultimate position.

Let the best 5 win but I hope it's Lambert, Jagusah, Craig, Billy, Wagner with Knapp being the center/guard next man in and Black being next man in at tackle. Absher is the sleeper at guard. He's a large human with potential.

Peter Jones could also become a depth piece at guard.
 
Yeah it does. He loves Knapp. He loved him as a recruit before ND. And rightfully so. But people have said (don't know ow if true maybe not) that he wants him to be the LT and isn't considering him interior. I dont think he is the best option there. I dont think you do either. And I don't think any other schools recruited him as a tackle. They recruited him as an interior guy.

Sometimes coaches really have an affinity for certain players. It happens to every coach
No it doesn't. You're basically questioning Rudolphs judgement and integrity. Knapp has certainly earned the right to compete for a starting position wherever they deem is the best scenario. Personally I'd like to see him cross practice for both the interior and outside. He's shown he's capable. I find it ludicrous that anyone would think a coach would not act in the teams best interests. That makes no sense. Your continued uninformed sense of thinking you know what's better for the ND football program than those who actually make a living doing just that is both amusing and quite pathetic at the same time.
 
I'm sure they'll cross train Jagusah, but I would expect we get a sense in the spring if he's practicing more at Tackle or Guard.

Does Lambert run more with the ones at LT or Jagusah? Could be telling

I'd prefer Knapp starts doing snapping training at center, I think that's his ultimate position.

Let the best 5 win but I hope it's Lambert, Jagusah, Craig, Billy, Wagner with Knapp being the center/guard next man in and Black being next man in at tackle. Absher is the sleeper at guard. He's a large human with potential.

Peter Jones could also become a depth piece at guard.
You like Jagusah better at left guard ? I thought Schrauth really blossomed there last year and Jagusah next to Wagner is very intriguing. Lambert is the wild card in my opinion. I think he makes the leap. Realistically if he was an early enrollee last year he likely gets the call over Knapp. Having a spring practice under his belt really benefited Knapp. His injury will likely limit his spring participation also. Otting likely to get most of the reps at center this spring I would think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kelso86
This is going to be one hell of an interesting Spring for ND football. Starting positions are not necessarily decided in Spring alone, but it offers a great opportunity for players to separate from the competition. You can make an argument for multiple position fights, but the three areas that intrigue me the most are:

QB is the obvious starting point. Angeli has done everything asked of him and done it well when given the opportunity. He’s our only QB with anything close to experience. Carr shined last Spring and gets accolades galore over his poise and passing skills and commitment to constant improvement. Minchey has a great arm and superior running ability, and seems a really good fit for Denbrock’s offense. Really hope one separates from the others, but doubt it. Kind of expect this decision to be drawn out to Fall with hopes of keeping all three on the roster.

OL presents some tough decisions as well. Lambert and Craig and Knapp and Black stand out to me as the big question marks. I think Jagusah and Schrauth and Wagner are locks to start. Craig was a tremendous upgrade when he captured the center position, but he is a question mark because of his knee injury and surgery. Knapp was very good on rushing plays and average or below average on passing plays as our left tackle, but showed tremendous poise, really good skills, and excellent feet for a third string freshman thrown into the starting job a week before playing TAM. But Knapp does not have prototypical size for LT at ND, and his skills seems perfect of playing inside. The assumption is both Craig and Knapp start again this season, and if so, the only question is where Knapp plays…LT or guard, and that then determines where Jagusah plays. Under this scenario, I prefer left to right Jagusah- Knapp- Craig-Schrauth-Wagner. But is either or both Lambert and Black too good to keep off the field, and what about Absher, who is also a talented monster? I continue to think Craig is the key. If not fully recovered, I think Knapp moves to center, Lambert or Black to LT, and Jagusah to guard.

DL has so many unknowns. Out of an eight man rotation, about the only two that are locks and healthy are Young and Rubio. We know that Botelho and Traore are going to play a ton, just not sure when. Burnham and Jr were major contributors last season, but will likely find their numbers reduced by the return B and T. Does Onye return healthy and in playing shape to pair with Rubio? Does the Louisville portal transfer win that spot? Does Mukum or Dixon elevate? Where is Vernon in all of this? Can Hinish add good weight? Does Saviano earn a rotational role? Can Thomas build on his freshman resume? Does true Freshman Burgess become this year’s Young? Etc…etc….

Spring practice starts in something like twelve days, and I for one am looking forward to reading how these position battles develop, and looking forward to folks here posting what they are reading or hearing. I need my ND fix!
TelX

Can anyone explain what Carr’s elbow injury was. And also how it happened? There is much written about it but I have never seen an explanation of what the injury is and how it happened

Notre Dame's QB Battle Gets More Interesting

👉 FULL STORY: https://news.fanrecap.com/wxZkPu
 
TelX

Can anyone explain what Carr’s elbow injury was. And also how it happened? There is much written about it but I have never seen an explanation of what the injury is and how it happened

Notre Dame's QB Battle Gets More Interesting

👉 FULL STORY: https://news.fanrecap.com/wxZkPu
Ski,
I have no inside info nor accounts that I’ve read. I’ve been dealing with a painful elbow for a couple years now, and finally decided to see an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in elbows. Turns out the guy is a huge ND fan, so my fifteen minute initial appointment went about 45 min., to the chagrin of his assistants. He diagnosed my issue as golfers elbow, although I haven’t played golf in decades. And he opined that Carr probably developed the same from excessive repetitive throwing with too much wrist action. He explained that I developed mine from doing simple arm curls improperly…extending the wrist wide open and curling upward while doing the same with the arms. All I can tell you is that cortisone injections help for a couple months, but the pain returns. I’m doing special exercises to stretch the ligaments and tendons, and having dry needle therapy. He fully expects Carr to be throwing pain free after rest and therapy. That’s a view from 1000 miles away!
 
No it doesn't. You're basically questioning Rudolphs judgement and integrity. Knapp has certainly earned the right to compete for a starting position wherever they deem is the best scenario. Personally I'd like to see him cross practice for both the interior and outside. He's shown he's capable. I find it ludicrous that anyone would think a coach would not act in the teams best interests. That makes no sense. Your continued uninformed sense of thinking you know what's better for the ND football program than those who actually make a living doing just that is both amusing and quite pathetic at the same time.
No I'm not. That's a silly ridiculous statement. I agree he has earned the right. And I have him as the starting guard and possibly center. Your comment was just way off base and not even what I said. Your bias is showing. Pathetic attempt by you.

Every coach has biases and for you to act like a coach has never made a wrong decision or a biased one is just wrong and insane

Awful post
 
Ski,
I have no inside info nor accounts that I’ve read. I’ve been dealing with a painful elbow for a couple years now, and finally decided to see an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in elbows. Turns out the guy is a huge ND fan, so my fifteen minute initial appointment went about 45 min., to the chagrin of his assistants. He diagnosed my issue as golfers elbow, although I haven’t played golf in decades. And he opined that Carr probably developed the same from excessive repetitive throwing with too much wrist action. He explained that I developed mine from doing simple arm curls improperly…extending the wrist wide open and curling upward while doing the same with the arms. All I can tell you is that cortisone injections help for a couple months, but the pain returns. I’m doing special exercises to stretch the ligaments and tendons, and having dry needle therapy. He fully expects Carr to be throwing pain free after rest and therapy. That’s a view from 1000 miles away!
Carr is already 100%
 
  • Like
Reactions: IrishMike409
All I know is it's every coaches dream to have this kind of a problem due to over abundance of TALENT! STACKED FOR YEARS TO COME!!🍀OLU
 
  • Like
Reactions: echowaker
Ski,
I have no inside info nor accounts that I’ve read. I’ve been dealing with a painful elbow for a couple years now, and finally decided to see an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in elbows. Turns out the guy is a huge ND fan, so my fifteen minute initial appointment went about 45 min., to the chagrin of his assistants. He diagnosed my issue as golfers elbow, although I haven’t played golf in decades. And he opined that Carr probably developed the same from excessive repetitive throwing with too much wrist action. He explained that I developed mine from doing simple arm curls improperly…extending the wrist wide open and curling upward while doing the same with the arms. All I can tell you is that cortisone injections help for a couple months, but the pain returns. I’m doing special exercises to stretch the ligaments and tendons, and having dry needle therapy. He fully expects Carr to be throwing pain free after rest and therapy. That’s a view from 1000 miles away!
I had a right elbow release many years ago and it hasn't bothered me since. Did the whole cortisone thing 4 times in one year. It helped with the pain but didn't cure anything. The release was awesome. Disconnected the tendon, cleaned up the scar tissue and reattached. It's been great ever since. Good luck with yours going forward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Telx1
No I'm not. That's a silly ridiculous statement. I agree he has earned the right. And I have him as the starting guard and possibly center. Your comment was just way off base and not even what I said. Your bias is showing. Pathetic attempt by you.

Every coach has biases and for you to act like a coach has never made a wrong decision or a biased one is just wrong and insane

Awful post
Continually woefully uninformed.
 
Continually woefully uninformed.
Your blinders are always on. No coach is ever bad. No coach can ever make a mistake. They always play the right guy. They always choose the right guy in recruiting. They always treat and coach each player properly.

Another awful post by you
 
No it doesn't. You're basically questioning Rudolphs judgement and integrity. Knapp has certainly earned the right to compete for a starting position wherever they deem is the best scenario. Personally I'd like to see him cross practice for both the interior and outside. He's shown he's capable. I find it ludicrous that anyone would think a coach would not act in the teams best interests. That makes no sense. Your continued uninformed sense of thinking you know what's better for the ND football program than those who actually make a living doing just that is both amusing and quite pathetic at the same time.
Exactly. You get the best players on the field, and if that requires changing their position and they can play it well, so be it. The coaches know best because they are with the players, as opposed to us who see clips here and there, or live game action that doesn't show what actual coaches film shows.
 
No. Every other school recruited him as an interior guy. Were they all wrong 🤣. All you care about is personal with me. Not about reality. Not about having a discussion. It's really pathetic. I believe Harry viewed as an interior guy and didn't offer him.

So not every coach has the same opinion and the coaches aren't right on every player either.
My comment clearly went over your head. Learn to read between the lines.
 
Exactly. You get the best players on the field, and if that requires changing their position and they can play it well, so be it. The coaches know best because they are with the players, as opposed to us who see clips here and there, or live game action that doesn't show what actual coaches film shows.
Yes. Coaches know more than us. True statement.

Also a true statement, coaches are human and make mistakes.
 
Opinions! That’s largely what makes these boards fun to read. Golson happens to express his in terms that come across as fact, but they are for the most part, opinions. I happen to agree that coaches have their biases, and these biases impact their decisions. Biases take on many forms…height-weight-arm length-athleticism, personal characteristics, etc… Their biases are the traits they value in the positions they coach, and of course, they rightfully believe these are in the best interest of the team and winning. I think Rudolph loves Knapp’s skill set and mental grasp of the game, and I think he fully admires how well Knapp handled the pressure of being a surprise starter last year, thus his bias. I think it will take a lot to convince Rudolph to move Knapp inside. Hoping that is the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Golson5
I think Rudolph loves Knapp’s skill set and mental grasp of the game, and I think he fully admires how well Knapp handled the pressure of being a surprise starter last year, thus his bias.

These observations are more evidence than just bias.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZibbyQuinn
This is going to be one hell of an interesting Spring for ND football. Starting positions are not necessarily decided in Spring alone, but it offers a great opportunity for players to separate from the competition. You can make an argument for multiple position fights, but the three areas that intrigue me the most are:

QB is the obvious starting point. Angeli has done everything asked of him and done it well when given the opportunity. He’s our only QB with anything close to experience. Carr shined last Spring and gets accolades galore over his poise and passing skills and commitment to constant improvement. Minchey has a great arm and superior running ability, and seems a really good fit for Denbrock’s offense. Really hope one separates from the others, but doubt it. Kind of expect this decision to be drawn out to Fall with hopes of keeping all three on the roster.

OL presents some tough decisions as well. Lambert and Craig and Knapp and Black stand out to me as the big question marks. I think Jagusah and Schrauth and Wagner are locks to start. Craig was a tremendous upgrade when he captured the center position, but he is a question mark because of his knee injury and surgery. Knapp was very good on rushing plays and average or below average on passing plays as our left tackle, but showed tremendous poise, really good skills, and excellent feet for a third string freshman thrown into the starting job a week before playing TAM. But Knapp does not have prototypical size for LT at ND, and his skills seems perfect of playing inside. The assumption is both Craig and Knapp start again this season, and if so, the only question is where Knapp plays…LT or guard, and that then determines where Jagusah plays. Under this scenario, I prefer left to right Jagusah- Knapp- Craig-Schrauth-Wagner. But is either or both Lambert and Black too good to keep off the field, and what about Absher, who is also a talented monster? I continue to think Craig is the key. If not fully recovered, I think Knapp moves to center, Lambert or Black to LT, and Jagusah to guard.

DL has so many unknowns. Out of an eight man rotation, about the only two that are locks and healthy are Young and Rubio. We know that Botelho and Traore are going to play a ton, just not sure when. Burnham and Jr were major contributors last season, but will likely find their numbers reduced by the return B and T. Does Onye return healthy and in playing shape to pair with Rubio? Does the Louisville portal transfer win that spot? Does Mukum or Dixon elevate? Where is Vernon in all of this? Can Hinish add good weight? Does Saviano earn a rotational role? Can Thomas build on his freshman resume? Does true Freshman Burgess become this year’s Young? Etc…etc….

Spring practice starts in something like twelve days, and I for one am looking forward to reading how these position battles develop, and looking forward to folks here posting what they are reading or hearing. I need my ND fix!
I think the bigger question for the OL is not who starts, but who are the top 7-8 guys in the rotation. Assuming ND makes deep playoff runs annually. It's highly unlikely only 5 guys start and finish each game. I understand their decisions, but i wish Coogan and Spindler hadn't left.

QB race reminds me of 2007. Eerily similar. Evan Sharpley like Angeli, Demetrius Jones like Minchey, and Clausen like Carr.

I have no idea who will win QB battle. My take is Angeli is a guy who can do all things well, but isn't elite at anything. Minchey is the best athlete/runner and if Freeman wants a similar offense from last year, Minchey is the answer. Carr based on HS rankings is most likely to play on Sundays, but is he ready?

I personally am rooting for Minchey, as dual threat QBs are so difficult to defend. If you use them right, they open up both the run and the pass game, as they can confuse the heck out of the LOS for the defense. The big question with Minchey is can he elevate the passing game. I do believe ND will have a better WR group with Fields on board and others developing. If ND can continue its success running the ball, which i believe they will and improve passing attack. Man, watch out.

I believe the potential is there to have a top 10 offense next year.

As for D-line, I think ND will be very good but biggest concern is DT. I think we're going to need a 6 man rotation. My guess is Rubio and Dawson start with Hinish and Onye in the rotation. Then we need 2 of Mukam, Vernon, Houston or Huges to emerge. But there are also others like Sevillano and Dixon who could surprise.

DE I think will be very good. Botelho and Young as starters. Traore and JT i think are next in line. Then you got Burnham, Thomas, Mullins, and Burgess knocking on the door.

Im very curious who takes over Watts spot. You got Stronmam, Talich, Johnson, and Blair as my guess for candidates. My guess is Stronman starts as i dont think he would have been recruited if Mickens believed Talich, Johnson, or Blair could take over.

I see no reason why ND can't have a top 10 defense next year. However, my biggest concern is how does Ash do taking over for Golden? Being a defensive coordinator is so tough because you have this balancing act of staying true to your identity and calling what you want to call or having to adjust to the offense. Diaco for example was great at having his guys play disciplined but simple football. But his scheme was too easy to figure out. BVG tried to be "exotic" and we saw how that turned out. Golden played a great balance of this. Played base D and would blitz aggressively. And when he would blitz, he would do so at the opportune times. I wont forget how he called the UGA game. He consistently called the plays that put guys in position to make a play. Play calling is an art. Ash has some big shoes to fill.

Is it August 31st yet!?!
 
Last edited:
I think the bigger question for the OL is not who starts, but who are the top 7-8 guys in the rotation. Assuming ND makes deep playoff runs annually. It's highly unlikely only 5 guys start and finish each game. I understand their decisions, but i wish Coogan and Spindler hadn't left.

QB race reminds me of 2007. Eerily similar. Evan Sharpley like Angeli, Demetrius Jones like Minchey, and Clausen like Carr.

I have no idea who will win QB battle. My take is Angeli is a guy who can do all things well, but isn't elite at anything. Minchey is the best athlete/runner and if Freeman wants a similar offense from last year, Minchey is the answer. Carr based on HS rankings is most likely to play on Sundays, but is he ready?

I personally am rooting for Minchey, as dual threat QBs are so difficult to defend. If you use them right, they open up both the run and the pass game, as they can confuse the heck out of the LOS for the defense. The big question with Minchey is can he elevate the passing game. I do believe ND will have a better WR group with Fields on board and others developing. If ND can continue its success running the ball, which i believe they will and improve passing attack. Man, watch out.

I believe the potential is there to have a top 10 offense next year.

As for D-line, I think ND will be very good but biggest concern is DT. I think we're going to need a 6 man rotation. My guess is Rubio and Dawson start with Hinish and Onye in the rotation. Then we need 2 of Mukam, Vernon, Houston or Huges to emerge. But there are also others like Sevillano and Dixon who could surprise.

DE I think will be very good. Botelho and Young as starters. Traore and JT i think are next in line. Then you got Burnham, Thomas, Mullins, and Burgess knocking on the door.

Im very curious who takes over Watts spot. You got Stronmam, Talich, Johnson, and Blair as my guess for candidates. My guess is Stronman starts as i dont think he would have been recruited if Mickens believed Talich, Johnson, or Blair could take over.

I see no reason why ND can't have a top 10 defense next year. However, my biggest concern is how does Ash do taking over for Golden? Being a defensive coordinator is so tough because you have this balancing act of staying true to your identity and calling what you want to call or having to adjust to the offense. Diaco for example was great at having his guys play disciplined but simple football. But his scheme was too easy to figure out. BVG tried to be "exotic" and we saw how that turned out. Golden played a great balance of this. Played base D and would blitz aggressively. And when he would blitz, he would do so at the opportune times. I wont forget how he called the UGA game. He consistently called the plays that put guys in position to make a play. Play calling is an art. Ash has some big shoes to fill.

Is it August 31st yet!?!
Good post and summation. I don’t view Minchey so much as “dual” threat but more of a passer with some mobility. I kind of view all four QB’s like that. My primary wish is that none of them transfer. Just keep the line moving and ND can use the QB’s in the run game a little knowing that there are solid backups.

I really feel like Ash will be running Freeman’s defense. Perhaps a couple small changes but basically the same thing. I do wonder how much Freeman will influence playcalling. Is it more “I want you heating them up”, or is it more “call the defense as you wish”. It will be fun to see how this develops.
 
As I recall, Rudolph was a big fan of Knapp’s before Rudolph came to ND; and he insisted then that Knapp would play tackle and not guard in college. This was in spite of others projecting Knapp as a guard at the next level. Frankly, I hope Jagusah or Lambert or Black wins the LT spot and Rudolph moves Knapp inside. But the operative word is wins!
The guy no one is talking about who I'm hearing great things about is Sullivan Absher. Not sure where he plays, but with Knapp coming back from surgery, Craig coming back from surgery, etc... He could make a move this spring. I think, given injuries and the long, long successful season (we won't see much of Love and Price this spring, Faison is all-LAX, Pauling coming off injury, nor will Fields be on campus guys Kedren Young, Saldate, Gilbert and Cam will get a chance to step up too. And that should be fun.

My big fear is the spring transfer portal. Pretty sure we're going to lose one of those three promising QBs and probably an Offensive Lineman, maybe a WR. Still, a far cry when we had to go to the transfer portal for Cain Madden.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IrishMike409
Good post and summation. I don’t view Minchey so much as “dual” threat but more of a passer with some mobility. I kind of view all four QB’s like that. My primary wish is that none of them transfer. Just keep the line moving and ND can use the QB’s in the run game a little knowing that there are solid backups.

I really feel like Ash will be running Freeman’s defense. Perhaps a couple small changes but basically the same thing. I do wonder how much Freeman will influence playcalling. Is it more “I want you heating them up”, or is it more “call the defense as you wish”. It will be fun to see how this develops.
Yeah, he has the best 'arm talent', easily in fact. With Carr, it's like he's more trained from birth or something. So he's got the pedigree and maturity or the know-how. I don't want to overstate just how talented Minchey is, but he's the higher pure upside guy. But if Carr is more efficient, more assertive, more effective, and he's a plenty good pure passer himself, then he'll probably be the guy. He's not a bad athlete either. I don't even really think of Minchey as that athletic at all. I certainly wouldn't categorize him as 'dual threat'. I do wonder if Carr would transfer if Minchey won the job.

And I wonder if Talich will win a starting spot at S. He hundred percent looks the part of someone who starts out as a walk-on at like, Iowa, and becomes an A-A, or a high draft pick. I figured someone overlooked like that would end up at Iowa or Minnesota or something. But ND managed to get him. I want that same cinderella success story.

As far as OL goes, if we have a future 1st rounder in Lambert or Jagusah, let's put them at LT. Knapp can learn to play inside, that's an easy adjustment.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT