Buchner is horrible and many here wanted him back over Pyne. If they can’t get a quality QB in the portal then all the talent they return next year means little. Buchner has 3 career TD passes but 8 INT’s.
No exaggeration, ND had the worst QB room in ALL of P5.
- Thread starter NDgreatestofalltime!
- Start date
Unless I am mistaken ND could have added a QB this year. The 2021 team would have been 8-4 or 7-5 without Jack Coan. But the Head Coach identified a weakness and solved the problem for 2021 in the portal.
That is how you win 11 games and stay in CFP and NY6 contention, As opposed to flopping around at 8-4
That is how you win 11 games and stay in CFP and NY6 contention, As opposed to flopping around at 8-4
Not until after the Cincy debacle when we had no shot in the Playoff. That experience would have helped him this year
Stop with your BS excuse, you screamed for him to replace Coan.
That just goes to show how little you know about football !
1. No I didnt
2. I said we ahould play Buchner after the Cincy game and I was right. He needed the experience for this year.
We wasted those reps
ND had 3 top 30 QBs on the roster, failed to make even 1 great, and pushed the best 1 out. And that’s not counting Jurkovich, who they also pushed out and would’ve been 4. That’s not a bad room.
You’re a hypocrite, you screamed for Buchner to replace Coan!
And now you’re trying to justify your horrendous decision.
You know nothing about football @nd even Lee’s @bout evaluating talent !
How can a top 10 program not get a QB? You’re on national tv EVERY WEEK! I just went through the entire top 40 and I’d take every opposing QB over Buchner without question. I’d take all but maybe 3 over Pyne
Before people start saying “no what do you have to say” after a 75 yard TD.
I say Diggs caught a swing pass at the LOS and ran 75.
I say Diggs caught a swing pass at the LOS and ran 75.
Your statement is proof positive that you know nothing about football
.I think this game proves me right.
And, if you compare Buchner’s and Pyen’s stats, they confirm my position.
Pyne is a year older and has more games played and reps
Since you know JS, why dont you apply for head coach and OC then?
How does this game provw you right. Ge has 2tds and 1 turnover. 17 points scored. How is that much different than Pyne?
If you had a brain, which you don’t, you’d understand the premise.
Have someone with a brain explain it to you !
You’ve just proved, again, that there’s no cure for stupid.
You don’t understand the premise, but still object to it.
You’re a know nothing moron !
That entire program is a dumpster fire, I like their coach personally but giving him these big extensions for winning some games every few seasons is ridiculous
TB would not start for any top 10 team in America. Those that want him to start don't prioritize winning. Hartman will make Buchner think twice about his future. I expect Minchey to start in 2024.
You guys are complaining about who Kelly and staff brought in. Freeman signed a very good quarterback in the current class. Brought in a very good quarterback through the portal. Has a top notch QB in the 24' class. The overall athletic ability of the roster is improving. I'm looking forward to this next season. I think we are moving in the right direction..
Pot meet kettle. Most posters here have forgotten much more about football than you'll ever hope to know. Pylon Pat.
You don’t have the intellect or the data to draw that conclusion.
Your a know it all legend in your own mind !
In addition, neither you nor anyone else explained the rationale explaining how an object that sits totally out of bounds, can be deemed in bounds.
If a player steps on the white line a millionth of an inch short or long of the pylon, he’s deemed to be out of bounds, but just one millionth of an inch longer or shorter when he comes into contact with the pylon, which sits out of bounds, he’s deemed in bounds.
So go ahead genius, explain the rationale, NOT the rule !
Prior to 1966, if a player touched the area where the pylon now sits, he was deemed out of bounds.
Last edited:
